6D Dynamic Range

Started 4 months ago | Discussions thread
Slideshow Bob
Senior MemberPosts: 1,073
Like?
Re: 6D Dynamic Range
In reply to roustabout66, 4 months ago

roustabout66 wrote:

Slideshow Bob wrote:

You may want to re-read the part I said about drab boring photograph and 14 stop DR. I show examples from 2 top Nikon shooters with MUCH less than 14 stop DR that are interesting, eye catching, and dynamic and ask you to show this DR advantage making an equally interesting photo and you show this? I hope you are trying to make a joke. If that is what 14 stops DR looks like I don't want it.

Sorry, but you're totally missing the point. DR in this context is simply sensor DYNAMIC RANGE. It doesn't LOOK like anything. It just allows you to capture more of the tonal information within a given scene. What you do with it is completely up to you. If it looks bad, it's because you made it look bad. You seem to be saying that because you've got 12 stops, you NEVER adjust contrast because, well, 12 stops provides the PERFECT contrast. You know damned well that you ALWAYS adjust contrast with levels, or curves, or whatever your tool of choice happens to be.

The only 3 things you've got are the DR of the scene in front of you, the DR of your camera, and the way you want the final image to look. If the scene has high DR, a higher DR sensor will allow you to capture more, allowing more options to achieve the look you want. You might not need it, but it does no harm whatsoever to have it. It's THAT SIMPLE.

I want to see a photo where the difference in 12 stops and 14 stops made a better picture. IT"S THAT SIMPLE.

So you expect me to have exactly the same shot taken with two different cameras, and compare them? Yeah, Right!

You were championing 5 stop Kodachrome a while ago. Why aren't you here whining about how 12 stop DR is only for measurebators? Is it because YOU'VE got 12 stops of DR? Is this like an ego trip? "I've got 12 stops, so 12 stops is god-like"?

You can make a 14 stop DR sensor do everything a 12 stop DR sensor can do, and more. It doesn't work the other way around. No one is telling you to change what you do. Enjoy what you've got, but stop acting like there's something wrong with people wanting, liking, or owning something different.

Free your mind dude.

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Post (hide subjects)Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow