Sirui T-1204x or T-1205x

Started 3 months ago | Discussion thread
mfj197
Regular MemberPosts: 494
Like?
Re: Sirui T-1204x or T-1205x
In reply to richarddd, 3 months ago

richarddd wrote:

I'd like a new small light sturdy tripod for my E-M5 and the Sirui T-1204x and T-1205x, each with the G-10 ball head, seem the most likely candidates.

They seem rather close in size and weight. The main difference seems to be that the 1204 has four sections while the 1205 has five. All things being equal, I'd prefer four sections, as that should make the tripod easier to set up.

For those with one of these:

Like Anders W I own the T-1205X.  I bought it to replace the Sirui T-025 which due to the fixed vertical column wasn't particularly stable in windy conditions.  I can't speak about a comparision with the T-1204X through personal experience as I haven't had one, but I can give you my thoughts on some of your questions anyway.

1) Why did you choose it over the other model? Does the 60mm (2.3") in folded size or about 100mm (3.7") at full extension make a real difference?

2) Can you setup quickly and easily? I'm a bit hesitant about a tripod with twist lock collars, as other tripods I've owned with locking collars required much twisting. Does four v. five sections make a real difference?

Yes, certainly.  One twist with a wide hand covering all of the twist locks will undo them all.  Occasionally I wish for a bigger hand for this approach - the four-leg version would be slightly better.

3) Are you happy with the ball head? Does it lock into place and stay locked, with no slipping? Can you move it slowly and smoothly and make small adjustments?

I actually kept the ballhead from the T-025, the Sirui C-10.  It's rather lighter than the G-10 bundled with the tripod and shorter too.  It does away with the friction knob, using the main locking knob to fulfil that role.  It has a huge amount of grip, no slipping at all, and is very smooth in its action.

The Sirui heads are excellent.  A recent German test of ballheads ranked the Feisol CB-30C top (88 out of 100), the Sirui G-10 second (82), the G-20 third (81) and the C-10 fourth (75) in the "under 100 Euros" category.  The test, in German, of the under 100 Euros category can be read here: 
http://www.traumflieger.de/desktop/ballhead/ballheads2.php

4) How do you carry it - in a bag, over your shoulder, other? When i carry lenses in a hip pouch and my camera over my shoulder, I'm wondering how I'd carry the tripod.

It comes with a decent quality bag with a good strap.  I do know the problem though - when I've taken the tripod on a shoot I've ended up carrying it over my shoulder as well as the camera bag.  I might get a slightly larger bag with tripod straps underneath.

5) Are you otherwise happy with the tripod?

Yes indeed.  It is stable, and as light and small as to be expected for the degree of stability on offer.  I don't have it with me all the time though - the T-025 was better for portability due mainly to the thinner leg sections.  The T-1205X comes in a surprisingly big box and the carrying bag is a fair size too, at least compared to the T-025.

Michael

Any other comments or recommendations?

--
http://fruminousbandersnatch.blogspot.com/

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Post (hide subjects)Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow