12-35mm Lumix ASPH for video -- strange jitter / OIS issue when mounted on a tripod

Started 3 months ago | Discussion thread
Anders W
Forum ProPosts: 10,841
Like?
Re: 12-35mm Lumix ASPH for video -- strange jitter / OIS issue when mounted on a tripod
In reply to John W Moon, 3 months ago

John W Moon wrote:

Anders W wrote:

OK. So there are reasons to suspect it might be a systematic issue. On the other hand, amtberg says he can't reproduce the problem on his GH3. So where would you say we stand on this? Design flaw or a problem affecting more than a few but not all copies?

And what about live view without actually shooting anything, whether video or stills? Can you see the effect in live view too (at least if you magnify)?

Anders,

I'm beginning to believe more that this is a systematic issue. One Vimeo user also claimed that he didn't see it. But if he had viewed it at 200% he would have found that indeed it was there:

https://vimeo.com/59492932

I guess it depends on focus distance, and of course, the type of footage being shot. (Fine detail will make the problem more visible, obviously.)

Anyway, the odds are there, and it's up to the individual user to decide whether or not this is acceptable. I tested extensively using two different versions of this lens. I saw it about 2/3 of the time. I also scrubbed through older footage I had before I discovered this issue, and I saw it. I hadn't noticed it the first time because the foreground subject was moving, but when I knew what to look for it stuck out to me.

I think this lens is still a good performer for many people, but for particular types of shots I'd use the 12-35mm with caution. Best of luck.

I am not really in the market for this lens (which merely means that its specs doesn't suit my personal usage, not that I think it's a bad lens). I am merely curious (and trying to help out by asking questions though you appear to have thought of most things already).

But what about the question with regard to live view as opposed to actual shooting that I asked?

And one other thought: If the problem is due to the OIS lens group not being held properly in fixed position, it could possibly be affected by power/battery status. Obviously, the thing should work as long as the voltage stays within the specified range and if it doesn't, it's a fault. But this is something that might be worth looking at for diagnostic purposes, just to get a better idea of what is actually going on.

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Post (hide subjects)Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow