How often do you crop?

Started 3 months ago | Discussion thread
apaflo
Veteran MemberPosts: 3,854
Like?
Re: No Crop often = Crap
In reply to Shotcents, 3 months ago

Shotcents wrote:

People who crop are usually people with imagination.

Nahhh, just that some imagine one thing or one way and others are different.

No matter how much you study a static scene or any other subject, this is not the same as coming home and carefully reviewing an image, understanding it's strengths and weaknesses and making final adjustments.

That is certainly true for me; but I see no reason that other people who claim otherwise shouldn't do it the way they do.  Different styles, different needs, but oddly enough the same good results too.

Outside of a studio setting (and often there as well), cropping is part of the artistic process. Those who don't re-imagine an image do little more than than record it.

Some people shoot one specific photograph.   You are right about they don't imagine there would be any other photograph than the one they previsualise.

But some are different. I see a particular previsualized image in many cases (much as described by Ansel Adams).

I also shoot a huge volume of experimental exposures much in the light of how Garry Winogrand described it:   "I photograph to see what the world looks like in photographs."  Only later, when editing, does the stage where a specific photograph with a particular framing allow cropping to be artistically even possible.

And we should note that for all Ansel Adams talked about previsualizing, he also was emphatic that the negative is the score, while each print is a different performance and should be expected to be as different as the person's imagination that makes it.

Cropping is part of the photographic process employed by most of the greatest photographers on this planet.

Actually, it's part of what every photographer, good or bad, does by necessity.  Cameras cannot capture the entire scene, and we all at a minimum crop with the camera.  We often move closer or farther and we often change focal lengths to change the composition of what we choose to frame.  That is cropping too.

My own style is often to crop as loosely as possible with the camera, and include anything that might be useful in an image under any imaginable circumstance.  Then when I'm editing for a print I choose which parts will be include in this particular print, and crop out those that aren't.  What is included changes when the purpose of the print changes.

I'll quote a well known photographer, but leave her name out to avoid flaming....

"Don't worry about perfect composition. Worry instead about allowing room to refine composition in the darkroom."

Well, I searched with Google and couldn't find anyone famous saying that.  But I agree except that "composition" should be changed to the word "framing".  We change framing when we crop.  The organization of what is framed is composition.

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Post (hide subjects)Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow