Anyone annoyed that the Nikon D5100 camera will NOT autofocus with some Nikon lenses?

Started 4 months ago | Question thread
b33g33
Senior MemberPosts: 1,070
Like?
Re: Hell yes!
In reply to eddyshoots, 4 months ago

eddyshoots wrote:

ScottHullinger wrote:

I replaced my old Fuji DSLR camera, which accepts Nikon lenses. And now I have a Nikon D5100 camera, which seems like a good enough camera, except that it won't do autofocus with the two Nikon de-focus image control lenses which I own! Why the hell not?

Well, answering "why" might be a waste time.

So ... which relatively new Nikon DX cameras of a similar megapixel rating actually ARE capable of autofucusing with those two lenses I mentioned up above? I've been seriously considering the Nikon D7000 camera. So are those two cameras similar in most ways, including image quality? With the exception that I HOPE the D7000 can actually do autofocus with those lenses I mentioned up above? Any help sure would be appreciated!

This is a systematic devaluing of the Nikon F-mount initiated by Nikon to sell more AFS lenses. Canon did it years ago in one fell swoop and was hated for it by many of it's loyal customers. Nikon learned from this mistake and has decided to take their time with the forced retirement of legacy lenses.

There are a lot of apologists on this board who are quick to forgive their beloved Nikon for just about anything. You will hear and see many arguments about how Nikon is saving us all added size, weight and cost. These arguments can't really withstand any logical inquiry. There are another group of folks, mostly new buyers, that are quite happy with what they have (all AFS lenses on an entry level body) but fail to see the long term ramifications of a company pulling stunts like this.....Nikon has done this in the past, they are doing it now and you can be damn sure they will do it again in the future. The next time the board of directors at Nikon feels like they need a jump in sales they will change the mount, change iTTL or change VR. Just a little something to force you all to prematurely retire your useless old AFS lenses. Then we will see a whole new generation of apologists...."This new AFX mount lens is worth it, who needs that old crap!".

--
eddyshoots

Here's something to think about:

Nikon is a 'for profit' company that relies on sales of it's products to customers. Customers base their purchase decisions on product features, price and availability and alternative products by other manufacturers. Customers expect product manufacturers to improve their products and incorporate the latest technology into their offerings. Any company that fails to do so, falls behind and runs the risk of becoming irrelevant.

Instead of imagining conspiracies behind every corner, you should actually applaud Nikon for retaining some compatibility for their entire range of bodies with older lenses. Unlike Canon, Nikon actually chose to keep the F-Mount when they migrated their lenses to newer technology like the ultrasonic focusing. All current and discontinued Nikon digital bodies can take F-Mount lenses and if you buy the correct model, you will even get AF. In addition, Nikon has always provided a relatively inexpensive consumer model such as the D80/90/7000 for those users.

It's quite amusing how you seem to take this all very personally. Clearly, the vast majority of Nikon users are perfectly happy with the backward compatibility.

--
What you know imprisons you

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Post (hide subjects)Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow