X series ISO Inflation

Started 4 months ago | Discussion thread
nixda
Contributing MemberPosts: 955
Like?
Re: X series ISO Inflation
In reply to nonicks, 4 months ago

nonicks wrote:

Can someone do a quick check with their 60D or 7D (if you do have one)? I dont have 7D no more but I have 60D.

Nothing scientific but I did a indoor shot using the 18-135 kit lens at 24mm Av ISO 6400 f/4.0, the shutter speed my 60D selected was 1/25.

I did the same thing with X-E1 with it's kit lens. at the same/close enough focal length, same Shooting distance and same lighting evironment, A mode, ISO 6400 f/4, the shutter speed selected by the camera was 1/25.

I did another shot at ISO 3200 , f/4 and 60D selected shutter speed at 1/8 sec while the X-E1 selected shutter speed at 1/12 sec.

The 60D was in evaluative metering mode and the XE1 was in Multi Metering mode.

So that means 60D's ISO is also inflated? I did not hear much complaints or test reports about ISO inflation from Canon 60D users...

For what it's worth, I did a quick-and-dirty test comparing my D7000 with my X-E1 at similar settings (ISO 800, same aperture, spot metering), took some shots and compared their histograms as well as compared the images on my monitor. Both cameras were very close in the chosen shutter speed; if anything, the D7000 did underexpose a wee bit compared to the X-E1.

There shouldn't be anything surprising anymore about manufacturer-stated ISO values. I think best is to figure out what settings give acceptable results and pretty much forget about looking at the numbers, with two exceptions: 1. comparing images from the same camera; 2. establishing conversions between two or more cameras in one's arsenal.

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Post (hide subjects)Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow