I don't care about video. Should I?

Started 4 months ago | Discussion thread
Spillicus
Contributing MemberPosts: 630
Like?
Re: I don't care about video. Should I?
In reply to William Porter, 4 months ago

William Porter wrote:

Spillicus,

Thanks for the reply, which I can relate to very well. Indeed, this is pretty much my reason for the occasional video, too. My #3 daughter was adopted from China in 2011, at the age of six. I took some simple home video with one of my early digital cameras at that time, and it's valuable to me and my wife now for just the reasons you mentioned: we can see how very very different she was at that age, especially because she couldn't yet speak English. I can completely see the value in capturing occasional moments like that — almost the more ordinary, the better. Just to capture the sound of voices, someone's facial expressions as they happen, etc.

But is that really why Sony is putting so much effort into video in its top digital cameras like the A99 and A77? DO I really need AVCHD to take 45 seconds of video (with stereo audio) of my dogs running around in the backyard? I don't think Facebook's standards are that high.

Will

Quite right; do you really need AVCHD 1080/60p to upload to Facebook, just to have them convert it into a highly compressed stream?  No, not at all.  But this argument to me is somewhat akin to the "who needs a $2500 full frame DSLR to take snapshots of the kids" point of view too; you can get the same shots with a point and shoot.  It's more a mattter of what level of quality you find acceptable, and what level of creative control you want to have over the process.  I think most people can appreciate the difference in 2 pictures taken from the same perspective from my iPhone and A65, and I certainly do, and it's the same with the video.

I image the number of people making professional quality videos with the A77 and A99 are a small minority of those who own the cameras, but because Sony is developing sensors and processing for video cameras anyways, it's probably not a big cost to them to add the capabilities to the DSLR line, and for some subset of shoppers it might work as a competitive advantage versus other brands; I did consider the video capability of the A65 as an important selling point compared to the D5100 and one reason I spent more for the A65 versus the A55 (no A57 out when I bought) was that the video overheating problem had been fixed in the A65.

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Post (hide subjects)Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow