Why no in-camera CA correction on Olympus bodies?

Started 4 months ago | Discussions thread
ryan2007
Veteran MemberPosts: 4,721
Like?
Re: Why no in-camera CA correction on Olympus bodies?
In reply to Anders W, 4 months ago

Anders W wrote:

ryan2007 wrote:

drj3 wrote:

There appear to be three different topics.

Why does Olympus not implement CA correction for Olympus lenses? This is a good question and one that someone interviewing Olympus management should ask?

Why does Olympus not implement CA correction for Panasonic lenses? I would be surprised if they did. Does HP or Epson make it easy to refill ink cartridges with other manufactures ink? I don't know any manufactures that would want to make some other company's product more attractive. They may have done so if they had entered into some financial agreement with Panasonic, but they ended up doing so with Sony.

This is what I have been saying all along. Even though the lens all fit in the open format Panasonic and Olympus are not there to make the other one more successful. Something has to make them stand apart from the other and who knows what is a patented technology. For 100% compatibility don't mix and match body and lenses.

In what way does an Oly lens perform worse with respect to lateral CA when used on a Panasonic body than on an Oly body? And why should a RAW shooter abstain from mixing freely across brands due to lateral CA?

The problem is a real one only for OOC jpeg shooters, primarily for those who use, or would like to use, Pany lenses on an Oly body.

Ok, than its directed to JPEG shooters. If you have limited post production time or are not comfortable with RAW files or don't have hard drive space or just do not want to shoot RAW then by your admittance saying its a problem for OOC JPEG shooters than what I say is correct. Don't mix and match body to lens unless you want to shoot RAW all the time.

Sounds like an easy solution. Hopefully that does not mean spending More money on software to do open RAW files, the need for larger memory cards and determining how much you free time is worth for post editing.

Then you make a copy say for family that wants the images from the wedding or graduation whatever the event and now they can not open the images means more time for you making it JPEG friendly for someone else.

Choosing JPEG or RAW is more than just flipping a switch the whole process has to be thought out.

It is so obvious with this thread. It makes no difference if one company was a camera manufacture and the other electronics. You have Sony brains or maybe a diode or whatever component to make it work.

Same with Canon and Nikon and third party lenses like Tamron sure they fit and work and are nice lenes but they are not the same 100% as using the manufacture lens for the higher end over $500 type lens.

The stabilization part is SO Minor because all you need is a tripod, monopod whatever. The software correction etc is a bigger deal. You can get stabilization with some thought as this technology is new in the scheme of photography, that IS or IBIS tech.

How much computing power is necessary to correct for CA and is it lens specific and how easy is it to implement? While I worked for years as a college professor working with a group doing computer based decision support, have programmed in several languages, and worked for 17 years as OIT director for one college and Academic Computing Officer for another university, I have no idea concerning the difficulty of such implementation. While your PC may be able to make such corrections quickly, remember it has a much more powerful processor and far more memory than your camera. The camera has the advantage of having a program which can be specific to the cameras processor and lenses. Only someone familiar with digital camera programming and optics can answer questions about difficulty of in camera CA correction, and I do assume that several of the responders to this issue must have that experience.

--
drj3

Edited 4 months ago by ryan2007
Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Post (hide subjects)Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow