Caution ! Dynamic AF versus single point AF... !

Started 4 months ago | Discussions thread
Mako2011
Forum ProPosts: 11,099
Like?
No RGB input
In reply to rayman 2, 4 months ago

rayman 2 wrote:

SteveL54 wrote:

rayman 2 wrote:

SteveL54 wrote:

Are you referring to the focus sensor array being finer? How do you know this and how new is the change? Are you saying the D4 and D800 have finer AF arrays than the D3 and D700?

Steve

I quote the D4 broschure on autofocus sensor that is also partly used for color and matrix metering.

<snip>



Thats a 1005 pixels Af sensor on D300 D300s and D700 and D3 against 91000 pixel AF sensor

on the D4 !!!!!!!

Thats a lot finer and it works totally different !

Peter

You are talking about the RGB sensor that is in the viewfinder -- not the phase detection AF module which does the actual focusing measurements. The manual explains it helps with auto-area AF's face detection and 3D tracking, but doesn't say how it works with single area and dynamic area focusing. I suppose it can augment the tracking done in dynamic area by following the color of the selected target. The RGB sensor helps determine what focus point is used for AF if the AF mode allows a choice, so there may be differences in this selection process with the new RGB sensor. However, the major difference between single point AF and multi point AF modes remains the same. Multi point AF has allowed the outer points to be selected on initial acquisition if the selected point does not have enough contrast.

Anyway I'm not aware the phase detection AF module has been given any more pixels since the D3. I could be wrong about the newer phase detect module naming convention, but back in the CAM 2000 period and before, Nikon states that the module's name is derived from the number of AF pixels. See this Nikon article:

http://imaging.nikon.com/history/scenes/08/index.htm

So the Multi-CAM 3500 would have 3500 total pixels in the AF unit. They've tweaked the minimum aperture requirement for the central points and reduced the light level specification for the D4 and D800, but no mention of any finer resolution.

Steve

Thats the misconception of most of the people here ... the RGB sensor is just as important

for the af system as the actual phase detect aray.... Its the RGB sensor that selects where the

focus is put to and what parts of the array are mostly used,....

With the Multi-Cam 4800DX/FX. The RGB meter only integrates with the focusing solution in AF-Area modes "3d" and "Auto". It has no input in the other AF-Area modes. I think this was documented in the Hogan Guides as well. Not sure about the other Multi Cam units.

--
My opinions are my own and not those of DPR or its administration. They carry no 'special' value (except to me and Lacie of course)

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Post (hide subjects)Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow