Need a new calibrator?

I know I should get both but too big of a bullet to swallow right now.

I am just upset that I have been producing garbage again and not knowing it because there is no way of knowing it the calibrator is working properly. I re calibrated and my screen comes out the same way.

I am leery of Xrite because this is the second puck that has gone bad. I guess they last about a year or so.