Saying Goodbye

Started 4 months ago | Discussion thread
Rod McD
Senior MemberPosts: 1,045
Like?
Re: Saying Goodbye
In reply to rattymouse, 4 months ago

rattymouse wrote:

Rod McD wrote:

Hi Ratty,

You recently wrote a thread in this forum about your coming trip to Thailand and said that neither budget nor weight were an issue for you. Perhaps you can afford both a D800 and an XE1, keep your beloved 24/1.4 and try them both out.

That's never been how i purchased gear in the past but I have that as an option if all else fails.

I know I suggested it as a fall back to try both, but if budget is no object, I can actually see a reason to own both on an ongoing basis.........!!  The problem then becomes which one to take (unless you're definitely taking both.)

It seems to me that you are comparing two very different systems as options.

Yes.

An XE1 is not a D800 and vice versa. They're horses for courses. Different purposes. An XE1 is small and light and will be good at general photography but not action, sports and wildlife.

I dont shoot action, sports, or wildlife. I travel all over the world and like to document what I see. However, I'm a night owl and LOVE to go shooting well into the late evening. This is where I read that the X series falls down hard. Focusing at night when ISO6400 is barely enough to get an exposure seems very very poor.

I think you're right on that one - I omitted AF in very low light from my list of things that mirrorless is not good at.

It also doesn't come with options for long fast zooms, long tele primes, and TS lenses. It will do very well for travel, but perhaps not other interests you may have. The D800 will do everything and at better resolution, but will be heavier on your back when you have to live with it for weeks of travel. And you'll stand out like a sore thumb - it's not exactly a subtle approach to travel with a camera.

I never ever had problems with an SLR and travel photography

I too had travelled for many years before encountering any problems.  I learned the hard way that it can and does happen.  But it may never happen to you.  If it suits your MO to take a DSLR, and you enjoy it, keep doing what works.....

You have referred to your 24/1.4 quite a bit. We unfortunately have to use camera systems as a whole, and can't cherry pick lenses and bodies. If you do buy a D800 it won't give you, the 35mm FOV. It'll be 24mm, and good lens though it is, let's not pretend that it doesn't have faults

The ONLY fault of the 24mm f/1.4 Nikon lens is weight. It is optically as good as it gets.

All I'm saying is that there are other great systems and lenses out there.  I wouldn't swing your decision on the retention of one lens unless its system is also what you really want.  It's the photographer that counts more than the gear. In other words, with sound gear,  you can safely buy into other systems and get great results.

FWIW, I don't own a Nikkor 24/1.4, but it wouldn't be my first preference for my interests despite the fact that I use the 24mm FOV a lot.  You've been using it on APSC where its sweet spot benefits the smaller format.  My reading suggests that its corner performance on FF is typical of fast WAs - not sharp in the corners until it's stopped down a bit.  Whether that matters or not probably depends on your interests and what you're shooting.  Personally I prefer slightly slower lenses with more even performance - eg Zeiss -  but then they're MF and I'm into landscape.

and there aren't other very good lenses out there........ (in either the 24mm or 35mm FOV).

Don't stress - Buy what yuo need now. There will in any case be a better camera than either to tempt you in a year or two's time.

I tend to keep cameras 4-5 years at least so I shop hard to get the right gear first.

Me too, generally speaking - sensible policy.  I do confess to braking this on occasion.  Sometimes technology leaps ahead or prices fall and there's little merit in sticking with the existing kit.

Thanks for your reply.

Happy decision making.

Rod

Cheers, Rod

--
DISCLAIMER: The text written herein is meant to provide the opinions and/or suggestions of the author. No statement herein is meant to be considered law of the land, representative of any party or group, and or a quote from any party or group. Neither is any statement in the contained text meant to be taken as scripture, doctrine, or all encompassing of an entire populous or any groups or individuals therein.

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Post (hide subjects)Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow