Warning to others migrating your OS to a SSD

Started 5 months ago | Discussions thread
Richard
Veteran MemberPosts: 3,049
Like?
Re: The OP needed the windows disk because the recovery partition was bad.
In reply to MikeFromMesa, 5 months ago

MikeFromMesa wrote:

Richard wrote:

That is what I said, it does not matter how you make the backup image. The reason I suggested taking the drive out and putting it into another computer and doing the backup is that we know this will always work.

Now lets say you get a brand new laptop and you do a backup image of all the partitions on a laptop computer to the second drive on that same laptop. It becomes corrupt. You then insert the recovery disk from the backup software but because your backup software does not recognize the disk controller, it does not see either disk. What do you do?

It is not clear to me exactly what point you are trying to make.

Yes, you are not getting the problem the OP had and why your backup would not help.

But if the recovery partition is bad either from corruption of it is bad from the manufacturer, you have a problem.

If the recovery partition has gone corrupt I do not have a problem because I have the original backup which would then contain the original recovery partition which was good when the backup was made.

The original recovery partition was not good, it was bad from the factory, it may have been corrupt or it may have had drivers that would not allow the recovery to complete so it was bad from before it get to the OP, in this case if he would have made a backup, he would have backed up bad data.

If the recovery partition is bad when delivered by the manufacturer, then it cannot be used at all. However I still have the backup which is OK. Maybe the recovery partition will not restore the system, but the backup will.

Agreed, the point of my post which others agreed, you need a backup of your system before you start messing with it.

You can make the argument that a Windows disc is better than a recovery partition because the recovery partition may be bad when delivered, but a similar case can be made that the installation disc could be bad (scratched, demagnitized, etc) when delivered. Further, I am less likely to lose the recovery partition than the installation disc or, since I probably have hundreds of cds and dvds, mixed up somewhere that will take me an hour to find. And, of course, I am far less likely to scratch the recovery disc than the installation dvd.

I am not sure what point you are trying to make, I never said anything against this. The OP did not backup his system, he relied on the recovery partition which was bad, he now does not have a backup or a recovery partition so he has a paperweight on his desk. He had to call Dell. My point after that was always have a backup of your system.

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Post (hide subjects)Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow