Does overexposing help get a better RAw file in the OMd?

Started 5 months ago | Discussion thread
Anders W
Forum ProPosts: 10,812
Like?
Re: Does overexposing help get a better RAw file in the OMd?
In reply to gollywop, 5 months ago

gollywop wrote:

Anders W wrote:

gollywop wrote:

For the most part, you are correct. There are situations, however, where your shooting requirements imply a shot for which the highlights are significantly below the r.h. edge of the histogram (or near the onset of blinkies). Say you're shooting in a dark room, have aperture as large as appropriate for DoF, handheld, no flash available (or desirable), shutter speed already on the too-long side, and ISO at the top of the relevant ISOless/ISOfull range -- and still you're not filling the ADU buckets. You've done the best you can; you've just taken a shot that, under the circumstances, maximizes s/n; you've just shot ETTR, and highlights are not the issue.

Well, it was exactly such a scenario I had in mind. You prefer to say this is still ETTR. I prefer to say it's not ETTR but that it makes sense to do what you describe anyway. Of course one reservation would be that neither you or I would ever shoot at ISO 25,600 with the E-M5, let alone shoot at that ISO without filling the "ADU buckets". From about ISO 1600 it's no better (except possibly for noise quantization errors) to crank up the ISO and expose up to the clipping point than to stay at a lower ISO and stay some distance away from the clipping point. On the other hand cranking up the ISO while retaining the same exposure won't do any harm either as long as you know where you have your highlights.

In short, we just prefer to use the word ETTR in slightly different ways, without any substantive disagreement of what it makes sense to do.

Well I don't disagree that the use becomes somewhat precious relative to the normal use of ETTR. So call it EMSN, Exposure for Maximum Signal to Noise, of which, ETTR is the special case when the highlights are pushed to the r.h. edge (or to the desired clipping).

Very nice solution to the terminology issue I think.

If you haven't seen it already, you might also want to have a look at what goes on at intermediate ISOs, where there are some pecularities to be aware of between ISO 200 and 400. See here:
http://forums.dpreview.com/forums/post/41988325

Yes, Anders, I saw that post when you first published it, and, on its basis, I immediately changed my menu to make the ISO Step 1EV.

Fine! And merry X-mas!

--
gollywop

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Post (hide subjects)Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow