FT v MFT lenses

Started 5 months ago | Discussion thread
Louis_Dobson
Forum ProPosts: 26,269
Like?
Re: FT v MFT lenses
In reply to mapgraphs, 5 months ago

mapgraphs wrote:

Louis_Dobson wrote:

In the meantime can someone explain why the FT lenses have an inherent advantage over MFT ones?
I think you could make a massive, high quality white elephant zoom for MFT as easily as FT. Far better of course to provide manageable zooms (say f2.8-f3.5) and very high quality primes. If one is prepared to cart around huge zooms, one might as well put a huge sensor behind them.


I think sometimes when discussing 4/3 lenses compared to m4/3 lenses people sometimes overlook that both sets of glass are designed and made for the same sized sensor. In other words, if one wants the design, speed and construction of say the ZD 12-60 in m4/3, they're going to get the ZD 12-60 with a m4/3 mount. It won't be smaller or lighter or faster or slower, it will be what Olympus has already designed for the 4/3 sensor.

I reread the DPR review of the Panasonic m4/3 7-14 and the comparison was with the Olympus M.Zuiko ED 9-18, not the ZD 7-14. Apparently Panasonic took some design shortcuts with their m4/3 7-14 that are corrected in camera (on Panasonic cameras only). The ZD 7-14 design doesn't use in camera correction, it is built with the corrections in the lens (hence the cost).

One advantage the m4/3 mount has (at the moment) is that it can take almost the entire M and LTM catalogue (less some of the wides), Zeiss, Canon, Nikon, Cosina and Leitz etc. And mount the HG and SHG catalogue.

No, at the wide end that's wrong.  Wide angles can be made the same quality but much more compact if the back of the lens can intrude into the mirror box.  As a landscaper, who uses mostly wides, that's the attraction.  The Panny 7-14 MFT is as good as the Oly FT 7-14, but a fraction of the size.
If you want an MFT 50-200 f2.8-f3.5 of the same quality as the FT offering, it will be the same size.  Which is presumably why such a lens has not yet been made.   It will come, I expect, around the time of the new camera.  For now, at the long tele end, you get cheapish, slowish, smallish efforts.

--
www.flickr.com/photos/acam http://thegentlemansnapper.blogspot.com

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Post (hide subjects)Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow