diiferent skin tones after calibration

i have 2 monitors both calibrated with a spyder 4. An old sycmaster 22 inch and a new samsung 850dw. After calibration and comparing them side by side the colors are basically identical except for just the skin tones. The old 22 inch has the skin tones reder while the samsung borders on an orange skin tone. Whewn i print off using both monitors and their respective profiles its the old monitor thats actually more accurate. So not sure whats going on here and what can be causing the orangy skin tones.