What's wring with the 1.4/35?

When I purchased my 35mm f1.4 G lens I was deciding between it & the 24mm 1.4 G. Since I also had several options at 24mm I decided to get the 35 first. Great decision, I love this lens. It is just magic! If lens tip says it's a dud than I will not bother with their reviews. I am always impressed with the look of the images I take with this lens. It is a favorite lens in my bag & on my camera.

Fred