What is the advantage of an optical viewfinder over an electronic viewfinder?

Started 5 months ago | Discussions thread
Chris R-UK
Forum ProPosts: 10,080
Like?
Re: EVF vs. OVF comparison
In reply to Alphoid, 5 months ago

On the whole I agree with your very good summary but I would like to add some comments:

Alphoid wrote:

Optical:

  1. Full color gamut, resolution, and dynamic range of the eye
  2. Coarse manual focus is still faster with OVF.
  3. You can upgrade to split prism focus screen
  4. Doesn't use battery. Both extends battery life, and usable with camera turned off.
  5. Instant. No lag. This was a severe problem with EVFs. Modern EVFs can be very fast, although they get worse in low light

I shoot with both EVFs and OVFs and I have never yet come across a practical situation where "EVF" lag had any effect on my photography.  In fact, I find EVF lag to be undetectable.

For me the number 1 advantage of OVFs is the ability to use PDAF for continuous focusing.  With the possible exception of the Nikon 1 series, no mirrorless camera yet has usable AF-C for small, fast moving subjects.  This is the main reason that I still have a DSLR.

Another big, but decreasing OVF advantage - no noticeable viewfinder blackout at high fps rates.

Electronic

  1. You see white balance, gamut limitations of the sensor, etc. before you shoot.
  2. You see exposure before you shoot. Beginners can do full manual from day one.
  3. Focus zoom makes for hyperaccurate manual focus (and better use of autofocus)
  4. Camera sees what it is shooting -- smarter automatic modes.
  5. No moving mirror. Less camera shake for sharper photos.
  6. You can review photos accurately.
  7. Potentially more on-screen information. Sadly, this is more theory than practice. Higher-end OVF cameras (D700, D3, etc.) start to add all the fancy electronic levels, etc. you see in EVF cameras. You just get them in somewhat lower-end EVF models. EVF models don't have fancy zones, etc.
  8. Much bigger image relative to entry-to-mid-level dSLRs.

(I don't seem to be able to insert this comment into the middle of a list).  Unfortunately there is a EVF equivalent of mirror slap - shutter shock syndrome or SSS caused by the double opening and closing of the shutter that is required with an EVF.  It seems to vary by body and lens with the Panasonic 14-42 X and 45-175 X lenses seeming to be the most affected.  Much discussed on the M4/3 forum.

Another major advantage of an EVF - you don't have to hold the camera at arms length for hand held video.

Switching from OVF to EVF is initially a bit painful if you're used to OVF. It took a while before I got used to losing the zen/connection to reality of OVF. Now that I got used to EVF, I have a hard time going back.

Not all EVFs are the same. Many of the cheaper, small sensor cameras have very poor, laggy EVFs. At the same time, not all OVFs are the same. Many full frame cameras have very large, very usable OVFs. I hate using APS dSLRs, now that I've used EVF, but a 5D Mark II is decently usable.

--
Chris R

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Post (hide subjects)Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow