Is the d4 better at focusing than the d800?

Started 6 months ago | Discussion thread
olyflyer
Forum ProPosts: 20,211
Like?
Re: I have all the evidence I need...
In reply to John Cote, 6 months ago

John Cote wrote:

Ralf Ronander wrote:

I don´t agree.

If you make sweeping statements like "D4 is much faster (at focussing)" you should be prepared to offer at least some evidence.

Many said, and still say, that the D3 was focussing faster than the D700, but IIRC Marianne Oelund showed long time ago conclusive tests to the contrary (while the D300 with the same AF module indeed was somewhat slower - not much but still).

Therre were certainly no evidence of the one being "much faster" than the other.

Hearsay die hard.

I hate getting involved in a fight like this but this is just insane. I am a full time professional motorsport photographer. I spent hours aiming long lenses on both the D4 and D800 through holes in the fence above the safer-barrier at Indy this year shooting cars and groups of cars coming at me at 220+ mph. The D4 with the same lens, same settings (close as you can get) and same technique could follow focus and give me consistently focused shots in a burst from far to close. The D800 was hit and miss at best.

You can tell me that this is not scientific but I don't have time to shoot test charts and brick walls. I have to produce pictures. My technique is pretty decent and my knowledge of how to set up a camera is pretty OK too. My customer wants to see motion and read the decals at the same time. The D4 and D3 will do it. The D800 won't. I never used a D700 so I can't tell you.

That's exactly what my guess was through shop tests and the specs. Unfortunately, Ralf dismisses such tests and claims that he is not interested in fps. It seems that for him it is the single shot AF which is of only importance, dismissing the AF connected to high frame rate.

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Post (hide subjects)Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow