RAW or JPEG? Which one when?

Started 6 months ago | Discussion thread
OniMirage
Contributing MemberPosts: 978
Like?
Re: RAW .... always ...
In reply to Kim Letkeman, 6 months ago

Kim Letkeman wrote:

G Sciorio wrote:

Hey everyone I was on a Hybrid Hangout with Will Crockett, Jared Polin and others talking about JPEG vs RAW

HH: RAW or JPEG? Which one when?

I feel that if you get it right in camera you don't need to shoot in raw. What do you think?

I think you are wrong. There is no such thing as "getting it right in the camera" ... it is in some ways doomed to failure because at the moment of the capture, you are also casting the final result in stone (as far as bruising the pixels is concerned) and compressing the result. This has two consequences:

  1. Any JPEG setting that is not exactly right for this specific image introduces anomalies that you may or may not be able to fix in post -- and can we really take the time to adjust every setting for every capture?
  2. Any error you make has much more likelihood for being fatal to the image because of the major difference in latitude during post -- can we really pretend that we don't make errors?

There are actually lots of other reasons and this has been beaten quite literally to death so many times that it seems surprising to have it come up again.

And note: I am not arguing with an individual's choice to use JPEG. I am arguing that the inevitable compromises must be understood ...

--
http://kimletkeman.blogspot.com

1: Are you shooting in auto mode and just selecting raw as the output?!?!?!? You should definitely be able to adjust all settings needed for a good capture on the fly.

2: If your settings for the camera ... focus, white balance, aperture, shutter and iso are all correct there is nothing that can go wrong other than poor software and really there hasn't been an article to date which says everything went wrong in a cameras software algorithms. We can absolutely make errors in judgement BUT lets say your focus is wrong, aperture, shutter ... raw isn't going to help with these regardless.

Let me also say that while raw can be used for the ultimate improvement, it can also be the ultimate failure if the person doing the editing doesn't know what they are doing. I have seen plenty of images from people over sharpening images, using too much NR, creating posterization, getting the WB wrong because of an uncalibrated monitor. RAW is not the end all, it never will be but I agree it is the ultimate way to "potentially" create the ultimate image. But it will not be the cameras fault if ultimately you fail to realize that potential.

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Post (hide subjects)Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow