If I could place the RX100 sensor in A500 for bird shooting, .........

Started 7 months ago | Discussions thread
DavieK
Regular MemberPosts: 461
Like?
Re: So, you're telling me...
In reply to cyainparadise, 7 months ago

Allan's post is an example of the kind of confident misinformation which pervades forums. I'd love just to be able to erase it permanently - because you never know who may read it, and have insufficient technical knowledge to realise it's a completely fallacious argument. Doesn't seem to matter how many other intelligent people point it out, this ridiculous position about 'less light' reaching smaller sensors (in overall dimensions) is a myth which seems to persist.

DPR's comparison refers only to equivalent depth of field, and even then this comparison only applies when the scene is scaled in all respects - that is, a 2.7m high subject photographed at 2.7m away (on full frame) compared to a 1m subject 1m away etc.

This is one of the things I love about small sensors - being able to shoot with 'miniature as full scale' effect, placing the camera on the ground, inside dolls-houses, within architectural models, inside a guitar, under the floorboards - or just to make an interesting plate of food into a full landscape foreground for a restaurant view.

There are specific cases where format change does affect relative lens aperture, and it's all do with subject scale. You can photograph an egg in an eggcup using a 2/3rds sensor camera, fill the frame, and your working aperture will be pretty much as marked; try it with 10 x 8 sheet film to fill the frame, and the required 2X magnification will turn your marked f/8 into a real f/32.

But at long distance, telephotography of birds etc, this is not significant even for extreme differences in film or sensor size. f/5.6 is f/5.6 is f/5.6 and never becomes f/15 - and the luminous flux, photons per square millimetre reaching the sensitive surface, remains identical.

David

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Post (hide subjects)Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow