Weight: system more important than sensor size?

Started 6 months ago | Discussion thread
rrr_hhh
Veteran MemberPosts: 5,523
Like?
Re: Weight: system more important than sensor size?
In reply to Tom Axford, 6 months ago

Tom Axford wrote:

ultimoamore wrote:

It seems to me that the weight saving has more to do with the what people want from the lenses, more than the physical issues that come from designing a lens for, say, FF.

What I'm trying to say is that people using m43 value more the small size/lightness of a lens compared to, say, a FF user; and lens designers put more effort in producing small and light lenses.

I think you are probably right. Canon and Nikon (and other DSLR manufacturers) have for decades followed a policy of making sure that their best lenses are their biggest and most expensive. This encourages photographers to spend more money and, indeed, some photographers actually believe that a small lens cannot be as good as a large one.

Leica and Zeiss (and some others) have not always followed this policy, however. For example, Leica's new 50mm f/2 APO-Summicron is better than their faster 50mm lenses, but lighter and smaller (although more expensive).

There are other examples from the days of film cameras, e.g. the Contax G Series cameras had superlative lenses that were much smaller and lighter than the best Canon and Nikon lenses, yet as good or better in IQ (although smaller maximum aperture).

and the Contax G lenses were AF lenses !  They are my preferred legacy lenses on mft bodies, very light and compact, plus they offer a super IQ, especially the 45mm F2.

Large cameras and lenses are a virility symbol to some and the manufacturers often pander to this.

When I realized that there won't be any digital acts coming for the Contax G, nor for the Leica M6 and got a Canon D60 instead, it was a real pain to adapt to those huge bodies and lenses. Yet there are some small and good lenses : the Tamron 28-75mm being one of them. At the beginning I thought that the big bodies were a consequence f the need to include all the electronics in the bodies, but with the n going miniaturization of everything, I think that Canon and Nikon have just been lazy.. May be that they thought that the big prices had to be justified by the size and weight...

Anyway : I'm very glad that there are now mirrorless cams : just make them full frame with short flanges and I'd be able to use my Zeiss glass like before.. (Aka without crop factor) .

--
rrr_hhh

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Post (hide subjects)Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow