Who needs Photoshop & RAW when you've got an X Pro 1!

Started 6 months ago | Discussion thread
57even
Senior MemberPosts: 2,197
Like?
Re: Who needs Photoshop & RAW when you've got an X Pro 1!
In reply to Fenwoodian, 6 months ago

Fenwoodian wrote:

Thanks for all the comments and interesting discussions. I am the original poster.

First let me say that I have LOTS of experience printing large (mostly 24x36 inch) prints on my Epson 7600. So what I have to say is based upon my extensive experience with this particular printer. When it comes to printing large, there is NO substitute for plenty of experience with a particular printer.

For large sized prints on an Epson 7600 printer, there is no need to print with files above 180 dpi - ever. I've done comparisions, and to the naked eye, I can not tell the difference between a 7600 print that is 180, 288, or 360 dpi.

The jpgs I'm printing from my XP1 are those where I've nailed the exposure. Only post needed is re-sizing and a little sharpening.

Finally, what I'm saying is if you nail the exposure on a jpg with the XP1, and the only post you need to do is re-size and mild sharpening, that when printed to 18 inches by 27 inches in size, the overall quality of the print is better than what I used to get from DSLR RAWs in the past.

I have not yet compared XP1 RAW prints to XP1 jpg prints. I hope to do that someday. Who knows what the results will be, but I certainly hope that the XP1 RAW prints are better than the jpg prints.

A million posts on that subject. IMO you wont improve on the JPEGs unless you really need to make fairly major changes to contrast, saturation or tone curve (where 8 bits limits your freedom a lot).

Silkypix manages to retain a little MORE detail if anything, but has issues of its own (very hard to match the JPEG colours, though someone did post settings for Silkypix Pro5).

LR up to this point rather mushes up fine detail and causes colour bleed into small light foreground details with saturated backgrounds - eg makes branches go green and white lettering on signage look like the colours ran.

Rumours also that Fuji are working with Adobe on this very issue, so we remain ever hopeful.

But for now, I am saying that the large XP1 jpg prints I'm making on my Epson 7600 are much better than I expected - and clearly better than RAW prints from my D300 and 5D DSLRs.

Noone makes JPEGs look this good. Somehow they squeezed a Cray into the camera...

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Post (hide subjects)Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow