Photo Edit Application

Started Nov 4, 2012 | Discussions thread
tomkinsr
New MemberPosts: 21Gear list
Like?
Re: Photo Edit Application
In reply to tomkinsr, Nov 13, 2012

I added ACDSee Pro and SILKYPIX to the bottom of this list as I was not aware of these products.

This serves to make this list more complete for others to refernece. It is important to understand that my personal observations are not to be construed as a definitive evaluation of any of these products, these are simply my first run observations.

They both have new ways of working with images that is non-intuitive (hm... this accusation is based on my traditional thinking of how an application should look and feel on a PC, which may be rather narrow minded of me). This would lead to a steep learning curve for me.

tomkinsr wrote:

The following is a first cut review of the applications I chose to evaluate. Some of these applications were installed, tried and uninstalled as they didn't make the cut.

I will be hanging on to PhotoLine, Nikon Capture NX2, DxO Optics Pro, RawTherapee and LightRoon 4 for further testing and evaluation. These applications exhibit good inital characteristics that warrant going through their learning curves before making any sudden judgments. I am seriously unimpressed with PhotoShop Elements 11, I had expected a more solid product with much better support by now. 64 bit computing has been around since Windows XP Pro and that was 2005, more than y years ago. C'mon Adobe, get with the program, same complaint for Corel and Serif. If you want the public to pay bleeding edge prices, then we should be getting bleeding edge technology. The stuttering menus in PhotoShop Elements was really disconcerting and even happened after a reboot so it was not an install artifact or anomaly.

The comments listed are my subjective observations.

RawTherapee

Free

  • Lightning fast browser
  • Geared to RAW processing
  • Uses Adobe Lens correction profiles
  • More menus than DxO Optics Pro or Nikon Capture NX2
  • Some Not Responding time
  • Geared to RAW processing
  • Professional level
  • Unorthodox User Interface, non-intuitive
  • Exhibits various bugs in User Interface and behaviours
  • Still a work in progress
  • I could do without the fancy scroll work used in some areas of the User Interface
  • Steep learning curve

Nikon Capture NX2

$134.95 CAD

  • 64 bit native
  • No png files
  • Professional level
  • Geared to RAW processing
  • Support for camera and lens
  • Llens correction profiles built into lens are then embedded into RAW file and automatically processed by Capture NX2
  • Lightning fast browser
  • User Interface is traditional with novel method for adjusting Black, Neutral, White and Colour control points and the level of influence, intuitive
  • Easy to learn

DxO Optics Pro 8

$99.00 USD

  • Lightning fast browser
  • Detected camera and lens and downloaded appropriate correction profiles, these profiles are developed through extensive optical testing by DxO
  • Does HDR
  • Uses GPU to process images
  • Professional level
  • No png files
  • Geared to RAW processing
  • Strong Rival to Nikon Capture NX2
  • Steep learning curve

Google Picasa 3

Free

  • 32 bit native
  • Limited Tools
  • Opened Nikon NEF files
  • Did a good job of indexing all images and moves
  • Rapid startup
  • Very clean uninstall

GIMP

Free

  • Steep learning curve
  • Lots of Tools
  • Lots of Menus
  • Lots of separate plugins to locate and install
  • Slow operation
  • Lots of Not Responding time
  • Separate Help Install
  • Sophisticated but not conducive to rapid workflow
  • Uninstall not clean
  • User Interface is non-conventional as is the multi-panel display arrangement
  • Steep Learning curve

PhotoFiltre Studio X 10.7.1

29 Euros

  • 32 bit native
  • Could not see Nikon NEF files
  • Lots of Tools
  • Very Busy menus
  • Rapid Startup
  • Dirty uninstall
  • Lots of separate plugins to install

PhotoLine

59 Euros

  • 64 bit native
  • Opens Nikon NEF files
  • Lots of Tools
  • Lots of Menus
  • Better feature set than Corel Paintshop Pro X3
  • Could be a keeper
  • Installer installed 32 bit native and 64 bit native

Lightroom

$151.99 CAD

  • 64 bit native
  • I could do without the fancy scroll work used in some areas of the User Interface
  • Various operations when changing menus are slow
  • No Layers
  • Steep learning curve due to User Interface

Photoshop Elements

$99.99 CAD

  • 32 bit native
  • The Organizer crashed while importing media, dropped itself down to offer Debugging
  • Slow to open Nikon NEF RAW file
  • Suddenly Windows complained the Synaptic Touch Pad driver was missing.
  • Funny thing about this, recently, all PC users with Windows 64 bit who had a fingerprint reader experienced continuous non-stop crashing when Adobe updated Flash automatically. It took them more than a month to fix the problem and that was achieved by regressing versions and then they updated that twice again and caused further crashing.
  • Menu selections stutter when moused over
  • If you open a RAW file as 16 bit, most of the important functions such as Layers do not work, you have to use 8 bit
  • Clean uninstall

ACDSee Pro

$99.00

  • 64 bit native
  • Steep learning curve, non-intuitive User Interface
  • Slow changes between modes
  • Seems to be duplicate menus with different functionality (eg White Balance) Control-Z did not work from a single change on the Edit – White Balance. The Undo menu was grey and not accessible. Icons had to be used to reset the change
  • The forced workflow is confusing and could lead to saved mistakes in processing until some level of familiarity is established
  • Multiple button clicks are required to exit Edit mode to be able to Save As…
  • The Online mode (BIG BUTTON) is of little value to me
  • Slow adjustments
  • No layers

SILKYPIX

$340.00 USD

  • 64 bit native
  • Steep learning curve, non-intuitive User Interface, menus appear to be randomly grouped and placed, this could be unfamiliarity with the forced workflow
  • No layers
  • Environment Setting has a big blue I beside each of two different button icons, which produced completely different sub-menus from each other, this is confusing
 tomkinsr's gear list:tomkinsr's gear list
Nikon D90 Nikon AF-S DX Nikkor 55-200mm f/4-5.6G VR Nikon AF-S DX Nikkor 18-55mm f/3.5-5.6G VR Canon Pixma iP4820 HP Officejet Pro K8600 +1 more
Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow