X-trans RAW conversion blog post

Started 6 months ago | Discussion thread
framus
Contributing MemberPosts: 836
Like?
Re: I disagree to disagree
In reply to David McGaughey, 6 months ago

David McGaughey wrote:

Yep. Egg on my face (not being sarcastic).

I do believe that I'm fairly demonstrating how ACR works.

--
http://www.dmcgaughey.com
http://frameandfire.tumblr.com/

From my experience I find David's perspective to be valid with one major CAVEAT. I see the 'problem' on SOME images with foliage not ALL images with foliage and/or high frequency detail.  I do not see this as a general/universal phenomenon.

In my opinion, this leads to the controversy and 'disagreements' about the WC issue.  The other factors that contribute to the confusion are that folks have varying criteria for IQ and workflows are implemented by each of us differently.

In my images I have yet to find one with fatal IQ flaws.  Fatal flaw for me is an image that is not acceptable to me when printed at ~25cm X 30cm. Note: I'm not the world's best pixel peeper nor do I examine my prints with a loupe.

-Framus

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Post (hide subjects)Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow