QUICK LINKS:VideosSample ImagesCamera TimelineLink Directory

connect.dpreview.com geasrshop.dpreview.com

News ReviewsBuying GuideSample Images Articles Cameras LensesPhonesPrinters Software Forums Galleries Challenges

Forum indexCanon EOS-1D / 5D / 6D TalkChange forum

Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?

Started 8 months ago | Discussions thread

Parent

First

Previous

Coyote_Cody

Contributing Member • Posts: 760

Like?

12

Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?

8 months ago

Going by DXO results it appears (maybe DPReview as well), many think Canon is 'far' behind in sensor tech on matters pertinent to good photos, especially to Sony.

Has anyone seen actual 'real' (non studio props) photos that show these 'crucial' shortcomings of Canon sensors? Surely they must exists if all these ppl say Canon is so far amiss!

TIA!

--
The Light is Right - Take that Shot!!
Check out my photo galleries @
http://picasaweb.google.com/TauPhoto

Reply to thread Reply with quote Complain

Parent

First

Previous

Post (hide subjects)	Posted by	When
Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	Coyote_Cody	8 months ago	12
I'm not aware of any issues regarding Canon cameras.	Apewithacamera	8 months ago	5
Re: I'm not aware of any issues regarding Canon cameras.	qianp2k	8 months ago	5
Confirmed my camera works fine.	Apewithacamera	8 months ago	4
Re: Confirmed my camera works fine.	Jon Rty	8 months ago	1
Yes DPR is not a good place to show photos	Apewithacamera	8 months ago	2
Re: Yes DPR is not a good place to show photos	Jon Rty	8 months ago	1
I stand by my post. Nikon = Meh..... to me.	Apewithacamera	8 months ago	2
Here is a bigger version on 24-70 II Ape prior to lifting shadows	Apewithacamera	8 months ago	2
Re: Here is a bigger version on 24-70 II Ape prior to lifting shadows	Jon Rty	8 months ago
you let us all know when DPR allows larger files ok :)	Apewithacamera	8 months ago	1
Re: I stand by my post. Nikon = Meh..... to me.	Jon Rty	8 months ago	1
What do I need Nikon for?	Apewithacamera	8 months ago	2
APC, thanks for sharing: haven't pushed mine that far but that's impressive!!!	José B	8 months ago	1
Thanks. nt	Apewithacamera	8 months ago
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	jm67	8 months ago	6
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	Press Correspondent	8 months ago	4
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	jm67	8 months ago	6
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	Press Correspondent	8 months ago	2
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	Jon Rty	8 months ago	1
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	Press Correspondent	8 months ago
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	Jon Rty	8 months ago	4
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	jm67	8 months ago	2
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	Press Correspondent	8 months ago
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	jm67	8 months ago	3
Fred Miranda, he does say...	rsn48	8 months ago	6
Re: Fred Miranda, he does say...	Ecorone	8 months ago	4
Re: Fred Miranda, he does say...	Turbo Hampster	8 months ago	4
Re: Fred Miranda, he does say...	Stone13	8 months ago	3
Re: Fred Miranda, he does say...	Jon Rty	8 months ago	4
Re: Fred Miranda, he does say...	Turbo Hampster	8 months ago	2
Re: Fred Miranda, he does say...	Jon Rty	8 months ago	2
Re: Fred Miranda, he does say...	Turbo Hampster	8 months ago
Re: Fred Miranda, he does say...	Jon Rty	8 months ago	2
Re: Fred Miranda, he does say...	nyc2012	8 months ago
Re: Fred Miranda, he does say...	Press Correspondent	8 months ago	1
Re: Fred Miranda, he does say...	Bobn2	8 months ago	5
What is going on at Nikon.....	VivaLasVegas	8 months ago	3
Re: What is going on at Nikon.....	VivaLasVegas	8 months ago	4
VLV for President!	Apewithacamera	8 months ago	2
Re: Seriously	showmetheprime	8 months ago	7
Re: Seriously	VivaLasVegas	8 months ago	1
Re: What is going on at Nikon.....	Bobn2	8 months ago	6
Re: What is going on at Nikon.....	Jon Rty	8 months ago	4
Re: Fred Miranda, he does say...	Press Correspondent	8 months ago	4
Re: Fred Miranda, he does say...	nyc2012	8 months ago	4
Re: Fred Miranda, he does say...	Press Correspondent	8 months ago	2
What's there to be confused about?	AllOtherNamesTaken	8 months ago	6
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	chrisP1	8 months ago	9
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	Press Correspondent	8 months ago	3
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	Coyote_Cody	8 months ago	3
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	rpiotr01	8 months ago	3
Capability enables possibility and creativity	Horshack	8 months ago	7
Re: Capability enables possibility and creativity	Press Correspondent	8 months ago	4
Re: Capability enables possibility and creativity	Horshack	8 months ago	4
Re: Capability enables possibility and creativity	Press Correspondent	8 months ago
I've been wondering the same thing, but...	Press Correspondent	8 months ago	6
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	vladm	8 months ago	4
The way I see it...	Tazz93	8 months ago	4
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	rrccad	8 months ago	3
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	shaunly	8 months ago	4
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	shaunly	8 months ago	8
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	Press Correspondent	8 months ago
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	rrccad	8 months ago
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	shaunly	8 months ago	1
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	Jon Rty	8 months ago	2
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	Press Correspondent	8 months ago
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	Jon Rty	8 months ago	1
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	Bobn2	8 months ago	2
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	Jon Rty	8 months ago	3
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	VivaLasVegas	8 months ago	9
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	Jon Rty	8 months ago	2
Re: Vegas doesn't "do" pictures	showmetheprime	8 months ago	3
You're absolutely right...	Richard300	8 months ago	8
Re: You're absolutely right...	Coyote_Cody	8 months ago
Re: You're absolutely right...	x-vision	8 months ago	5
Re: You're absolutely right...	qianp2k	8 months ago	1
Re: You're absolutely right...	Jon Rty	8 months ago	2
Re: You're absolutely right...	Press Correspondent	8 months ago	2
Re: You're absolutely right...	x-vision	8 months ago	2
Re: You're absolutely right...	David Hull	8 months ago	1
Re: You're absolutely right...	x-vision	8 months ago	8
Re: You're absolutely right...	David Hull	8 months ago	4
Well said David	Apewithacamera	8 months ago	1
Re: You're absolutely right...	Horshack	8 months ago	2
Re: You're absolutely right...	Press Correspondent	8 months ago	1
Re: You're absolutely right...	Bobn2	8 months ago	6
Re: You're absolutely right...	Press Correspondent	8 months ago
Re: You're absolutely right...	Jon Rty	8 months ago	4
Re: You're absolutely right...	Press Correspondent	8 months ago
Re: You're absolutely right...	Horshack	8 months ago	1
Re: You're absolutely right...	Press Correspondent	8 months ago
Re: You're absolutely right...	Jon Rty	8 months ago	2
Re: You're absolutely right...	Press Correspondent	8 months ago
Re: You're absolutely right...	Horshack	8 months ago	2
Re: You're absolutely right...	Jon Rty	8 months ago	2
Re: You're absolutely right...	Press Correspondent	8 months ago	1
Re: You're absolutely right...	Jon Rty	8 months ago	2
Re: You're absolutely right...	Gmshots	8 months ago	2
Re: You're absolutely right...	ak1999	8 months ago	4
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	cpkuntz	8 months ago
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	cpkuntz	8 months ago
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	qianp2k	8 months ago	2
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	cpkuntz	8 months ago
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	NRBlack	8 months ago
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	x-vision	8 months ago	8
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	studio311	8 months ago	3
I honestly think that this stuff doesn't matter at all..	Gearóid Ó Laoi, Garry Lee	8 months ago	2
Re: I honestly think that this stuff doesn't matter at all..	Bruce Crossan	8 months ago
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	Jon Rty	8 months ago	1
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	gdanmitchell	8 months ago	2
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	Turbo Hampster	8 months ago
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	NRBlack	8 months ago	1
What the hell is going on here?	Slideshow Bob	8 months ago	3
Re: What the hell is going on here?	Press Correspondent	8 months ago
Re: Unmeasurablebating	JohnnyRX7	8 months ago
Re: What the hell is going on here?	gdanmitchell	8 months ago	2
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	C D M	8 months ago	3
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	qianp2k	8 months ago	1
Go look at some Sigma DP2 photos	Searching	8 months ago
Yes & No	Rick Knepper	8 months ago	2
There's only ONE reason why	XeroJay	8 months ago	2
Here's an image	Horshack	8 months ago	4
Re: Here's an image	qianp2k	8 months ago
Re: Here's an image	Timbukto	8 months ago
Example	Timbukto	8 months ago	1
Re: Example	showmetheprime	8 months ago	1
Re: Example	Timbukto	8 months ago
Another example	Timbukto	8 months ago
Have you been able to correct the skyline to building transition?	Timbukto	8 months ago
Re: Have you been able to correct the skyline to building transition?	Horshack	8 months ago	1
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	RobNZ	8 months ago	4
Re: Spot On	showmetheprime	8 months ago	1
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	aftab	8 months ago	2
Did you not give any Exp compensation to the rather dark horses in such	Apewithacamera	8 months ago
Not a keeper	Press Correspondent	8 months ago	1
Re: Not a keeper	Bobn2	8 months ago	5
Re: Not a keeper	Press Correspondent	8 months ago
I was going to say exactly what you said!	Apewithacamera	8 months ago	2
This is really funny	Stepanfo	8 months ago	5
Re: This is really funny	Gary H	8 months ago	1
Re: This is really funny	Press Correspondent	8 months ago	2
Re: This is really funny	x-vision	8 months ago	4
none so far. every example shown is shot in good light, more often strictly high contrast scenarios	sdyue	8 months ago	1
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	aftab	8 months ago	3
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	MichaelIsGreat4	8 months ago	4
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	Turbo Hampster	8 months ago	1
Shadow noise recovery..is this that bad???	papparazzi	8 months ago	1
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	kimvette	8 months ago	2
Re: Lot's of critics of Canon DSLR sensors these days, any photo proof to support this?	ttylr24551	8 months ago	1

Parent

First

Previous

Keyboard shortcuts:

FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads

Color scheme? Blue / Yellow

Editorial content

Product database

Community

About us Write for us FAQ Feedback Interest-Based Ads Privacy Legal

All content, design, and layout are Copyright © 1998 - 2013 Digital Photography Review All Rights Reserved. Reproduction in whole or part in any form or medium without specific written permission is prohibited.

Mobile site