QUICK LINKS:VideosSample ImagesCamera TimelineLink Directory

connect.dpreview.com geasrshop.dpreview.com

News ReviewsBuying GuideSample Images Articles Cameras Lenses Printers Software Forums Galleries Challenges

Forum indexStudio and Lighting TechniqueChange forum

Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??

Started 8 months ago | Discussion thread

Next

UKphotographers

Veteran Member • Posts: 3,810

Like?

Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??

In reply to antares103, 7 months ago

antares103 wrote:

UKphotographers wrote:

Yes, below, almost underneath.. magic light again?

Below and out/behind. Thats why the ladder is curved. "Almost" underneath is not underneath. Like "kinda" pregnant.

The angle of that ladder just wouldn't contribute to any reflections off the boot in my opinion.

UKphotographers wrote:

Compared to the mythbusters image.. theirs is a lot more over exposed, yet even so their shadow areas are still a lot darker.

I dont know what mythbusters did, nor do I care. They do not have very good scientific method.

It seems others disagree and point to that, and the comparison I posted as evidence that the photograph posted by the OP was completely natural. Its far from the mark as far as I'm concerned.

--
Ian.

http://www.commercialphotographer.co.uk

Theres only one sun. Why do I need more than one light to get a natural result?

Reply Reply with quote Complain

Next

Post (hide subjects)	Posted by	When
Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	padang	8 months ago
It's not fill flash....but reflected light	Port Royal Dad	8 months ago
Re: Big silver reflector	GHwell	8 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	Barrie Davis	8 months ago
Re: Did NASA? Nope	drh681	8 months ago
Yes, if you simulate the photos from the moon...	LincolnB	8 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	UKphotographers	8 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	Barrie Davis	8 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	UKphotographers	8 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	tundracamper	8 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	PhotoByRichard	8 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	Ronan_M	8 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	UKphotographers	8 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	Barrie Davis	8 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	UKphotographers	8 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	Barrie Davis	8 months ago
How many people out there....	Quantum Help	8 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	kelstertx	8 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	UKphotographers	8 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	drh681	8 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	UKphotographers	8 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	Barrie Davis	8 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	UKphotographers	8 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	Barrie Davis	8 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	UKphotographers	8 months ago
I know. I know. You can't see the stars!	Barrie Davis	8 months ago
Exposure levels will be the same as on Earth	UKphotographers	8 months ago
Re: Exposure levels will be the same as on Earth	drh681	8 months ago
Re: Exposure levels will be the same as on Earth	UKphotographers	8 months ago
An unwillingness to say, "I don't know"	LincolnB	8 months ago
Why? A simple question - often requiring an answer.	UKphotographers	8 months ago
Re: Why? A simple question - often requiring an answer.	onedawg	8 months ago
Re: Why? A simple question - often requiring an answer.	UKphotographers	8 months ago
Re: Why? A simple question - often requiring an answer.	drh681	8 months ago
Re: Why? A simple question - often requiring an answer.	UKphotographers	8 months ago
Re: Why? A simple question - often requiring an answer.	UKphotographers	8 months ago
Re: Why? A simple question - often requiring an answer.	drh681	8 months ago
Re: Why? A simple question - often requiring an answer.	UKphotographers	8 months ago
Re: Why? A simple question - often requiring an answer.	Morris Sullivan	7 months ago
Re: Why? A simple question - often requiring an answer.	UKphotographers	7 months ago
Re: Exposure levels will be the same as on Earth	drh681	8 months ago
Re: Exposure levels will be the same as on Earth	UKphotographers	8 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	PenFan2011	8 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	UKphotographers	8 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	drh681	8 months ago
Please - NO hissy fits!	Quantum Help	8 months ago
Re: Please - NO hissy fits!	UKphotographers	8 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	PenFan2011	8 months ago
THEY NEVER WENT TO THE MOON... but who cares	svphotog	8 months ago
Re: THEY NEVER WENT TO THE MOON... but who cares	Barrie Davis	8 months ago
Re: THEY NEVER WENT TO THE MOON... but who cares	UKphotographers	8 months ago
Re: THEY NEVER WENT TO THE MOON... but who cares	Barrie Davis	8 months ago
Re: THEY NEVER WENT TO THE MOON... but who cares	UKphotographers	8 months ago
That was never five minutes!	Barrie Davis	8 months ago
Answered here	o_23	8 months ago
The last word from the Kremlin	nickoly	8 months ago
Re: The last word from the Kremlin	UKphotographers	8 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	AShimon	7 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	mike_nz	7 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	Barrie Davis	7 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	nickoly	7 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	Barrie Davis	7 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	antares103	7 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	UKphotographers	7 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	antares103	7 months ago
lighting the set, mimicking the sun	Peter Berressem	7 months ago
Re: lighting the set, mimicking the sun	UKphotographers	7 months ago
Re: lighting the set, mimicking the sun	Peter Berressem	7 months ago
Re: Did NASA manipulated the photos from the Apollo mission ??	UKphotographers	7 months ago

Next

Keyboard shortcuts:

FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads

Color scheme? Blue / Yellow

Editorial content

Product database

Community

About us Write for us FAQ Feedback Interest-Based Ads Privacy Legal

All content, design, and layout are Copyright © 1998 - 2013 Digital Photography Review All Rights Reserved. Reproduction in whole or part in any form or medium without specific written permission is prohibited.

Mobile site