Apple awarded $1.05b settlement with Samsung

Started 9 months ago | Discussions thread
Jon Ragnarsson
Veteran MemberPosts: 5,198
Like?
Re: sorry, that example doesn't stand up to scrutiny
In reply to T3, 8 months ago

Actually, Apple didn't win over Samsung 'rectangular rounded corner design copy', but something like this:

“A computer-implemented method, for use in conjunction with a portable electronic device with a touch screen display, comprises displaying at least a portion of a structured electronic document on the touch screen display, wherein the structured electronic document comprises a plurality of boxes of content, and detecting a first gesture at a location on the displayed portion of the structured electronic document. A first box in the plurality of boxes at the location of the first gesture is determined. The first box on the touch screen display is enlarged and substantially centered.”

WTF indeed...

T3 wrote:

Hahaha! That is an extremely simple-minded example that does not hold up to scrutiny when you did further into just how different these two phones are. It's not merely the fact that Samsung's phones have a screen that Apple went after them. It's really about the totality and comprehensiveness to which Samsung copied Apple's trade dress that was the issue. The degree to which Samsung copied Apple became too overwhelming to ignore, so Apple had to take action. It's as simple as that. Samsung just took their copying too far to be ignored . Samsung did this to themselves.

It's like if you annoy someone, that person may just ignore you. But at a certain point you may annoy someone so much and to such a degree that they'll pop a fist in your face. That's basically what Apple did to Samsung. Samsung copied so much that Apple could no longer ignore them, and so Apple popped a fist in their face to put them back in their place.

--
http://jonr.light.is

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Post (hide subjects)Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow