Olympus M5 - IBIS vs OIS with Pana 100-300 / Pana 14-45

Started May 11, 2012 | Discussion thread
luisflorit
Veteran MemberPosts: 6,716
Like?
Re: This is why...
In reply to Anders W, May 16, 2012

Hi Anders,

You show here the main reason why I didn't go m43rds yet. I shoot nature in bad light (rainforests), almost always with flash. And the OIS of the 100-300 is quite inefficient for 300mm at 1/160s (the slow max flash sync of the GH2). So the combo is useless for me (quite unfortunately).

Hi Luis. Well, the OIS of the 100-300 used to be pretty inefficient at the long end, just as you say. But things improved quite a bit with the firmware upgrade released at the end of January, which specifically promises to improve the functionality of the OIS, and actually does so according to my own experience as well as that of other users. OK, you wouldn't nail it on every try when shooting at 1/160, but unlike before, you have at least some chances of getting a really sharp shot. That said, it is quite conceivable that the IBIS of the E-M5 is even better.

Yes, you told me this before. Those are indeed good news. Probably Pany did something wrong with the original 100-300 firmware, since I remember that even the old FZ50 OIS was great (no problem handholding at 720mm equiv. and 1/250s).

OTOH, the OMD IBIS looks quite good and usable at 1/160. And the OMD flash sync is 1/250s!

This also shows an advantage of IBIS that I always thought about, but not many people are aware of. Lens OIS efficiency is constant: once you buy the lens, its OIS does not 'evolve'. IBIS, OTOH, evolves with the bodies, so the same lens gets better stabilized with time. That's why I prefer IBIS, even out of the realm of legacy lenses.

Well, OIS performance isn't quite constant. Luckily there are firmware upgrades.

Here's today's catch from the 100-300, both shot with the G1 at ISO 100 and max aperture. Didn't have reason to go as far down in terms of shutter speed this time since the light was reasonably good.

EDIT: If the images don't expand when clicked upon, as they normally should, try "open in a new window" to watch them.

Even a mundande Eurasian Tree Sparrow (passer montanus) can look rather colorful under the right circumstances (300 mm, f/5.6, 1/320 s, cropped to about the one quarter of the original size).

Sparrows are beautiful!

Nice shots!

Thanks,
L.

--
My gallery: http://luis.impa.br/photo/new

Oly E5/E3 + 12-60 + 50-200 + EC14 + EC20 + FL50R
Pany FZ50 + Oly FL50 + TCON17 + Raynox 150 & 250

Reply   Reply with quote   Complain
Post (hide subjects)Posted by
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow