Forum indexCanon EOS-1D / 5D / 6D TalkChange forum

Intersring Finding, must READ (5DM3 DR!!!)

Started May 2, 2012 | Discussion thread

Forum

KW Phua

Forum Member • Posts: 60

Like?

Re: You are missing the point....

In reply to SubPrime, May 2, 2012

When I faced problem related to shadow noise, I always switch from ACR to DPP. Hard to see banding in DPP.

SubPrime wrote:

ArabiaSandStorm wrote:

the point of the thread is the speculation is that LR is not reading 5DM3 raw files as they are supposed to, therefore shadow removal is limited. Comparing 5D2 & 5D3 in LR is useless in this case!

On the contrary. It seems rather odd that this issue has been around since the 5D2 were released and no one picked it until now.

Are we to assume 5D2 shooters have been putting up with this for 5 years?

--
KW Phua

Reply Reply with quote Complain

Post (hide subjects)	Posted by	When
Intersring Finding, must READ (5DM3 DR!!!)	ArabiaSandStorm	May 2, 2012
Re: Intersring Finding, must READ (5DM3 DR!!!)	Ogjetaknight	May 2, 2012
Re: Intersring Finding, must READ (5DM3 DR!!!)	ArabiaSandStorm	May 2, 2012
Re: Intersring Finding, must READ (5DM3 DR!!!)	Ogjetaknight	May 2, 2012
Re: Intersring Finding, must READ (5DM3 DR!!!)	RamiH	May 2, 2012
Very nice	SHillphoto	May 2, 2012
Re: Very nice	ArabiaSandStorm	May 2, 2012
Re: Very nice	GaryJP	May 2, 2012
Re: Very nice	SubPrime	May 2, 2012
looks out of focus. or camera shake?	chironNYC	May 2, 2012
Re: looks out of focus. or camera shake?	SubPrime	May 2, 2012
Re: Very nice	qianp2k	May 2, 2012
Re: Very nice	SubPrime	May 2, 2012
Re: Very nice	mgrum	May 2, 2012
Re: Very nice	ArabiaSandStorm	May 2, 2012
Re: Very nice	SubPrime	May 2, 2012
Re: Very nice	Ogjetaknight	May 2, 2012
Re: Very nice False and ignorant and physically impossible	Mikael Risedal	May 2, 2012
LOL	GaryJP	May 2, 2012
Re: LOL	aftab	May 2, 2012
You can stand by your statement if you want	bgbs	May 2, 2012
You feel	Kabe Luna	May 3, 2012
Re: You feel	ArabiaSandStorm	May 3, 2012
Speculation	Kabe Luna	May 3, 2012
Re: You feel	bobn2	May 4, 2012
Wow .... Caaaaaalm down	ArabiaSandStorm	May 4, 2012
Re: Wow .... Caaaaaalm down	bobn2	May 4, 2012
Re: Wow .... Caaaaaalm down	ArabiaSandStorm	May 4, 2012
Re: Wow .... Caaaaaalm down	bobn2	May 4, 2012
Re: Wow .... Caaaaaalm down	ArabiaSandStorm	May 4, 2012
Re: Wow .... Caaaaaalm down	asad137	May 4, 2012
Here comes the nikonian support. Nikonians Unite...	ArabiaSandStorm	May 4, 2012
Lame argument	SubPrime	May 2, 2012
Re: Lame argument	ArabiaSandStorm	May 2, 2012
Re: Lame argument	SubPrime	May 2, 2012
Re: Lame argument	Stoneh	May 2, 2012
Re: Lame argument	SubPrime	May 2, 2012
Re: Lame argument	GaryJP	May 2, 2012
Re: Lame argument	SubPrime	May 2, 2012
Re: Lame argument	chironNYC	May 2, 2012
Re: Lame argument	SubPrime	May 2, 2012
DR champ is the D800	Apewithacamera	May 2, 2012
More grasping at straws	B E	May 2, 2012
Re: More grasping at straws	joger	May 2, 2012
You are missing the point....	ArabiaSandStorm	May 2, 2012
Re: You are missing the point....	SubPrime	May 2, 2012
Re: You are missing the point....	KW Phua	May 2, 2012
Re: You are missing the point....	joger	May 2, 2012
Re: More grasping at straws	chironNYC	May 2, 2012
Re: More grasping at straws	SubPrime	May 2, 2012
wrong	tko	May 2, 2012
Re: wrong	qianp2k	May 2, 2012
Re: wrong	Stone13	May 2, 2012
Re: wrong	qianp2k	May 2, 2012
Re: wrong	SubPrime	May 2, 2012
Re: wrong	Stone13	May 3, 2012
Re: More grasping at straws	Mikael Risedal	May 2, 2012
Honest question for the DXO says folks.	Osiris30	May 2, 2012
Re: Honest question for the DXO says folks.	Mikael Risedal	May 3, 2012
Re: Honest question for the DXO says folks.	mforbes	May 3, 2012
Re: Honest question for the DXO says folks.	Osiris30	May 3, 2012
Re: Honest question for the DXO says folks.	B E	May 3, 2012
Re: Honest question for the DXO says folks.	Osiris30	May 3, 2012
Re: Honest question for the DXO says folks.	B E	May 3, 2012
Re: Honest question for the DXO says folks.	Mikael Risedal	May 3, 2012
Re: Honest question for the DXO says folks.	yabokkie	May 3, 2012
Re: Honest question for the DXO says folks.	B E	May 3, 2012
Re: Honest question for the DXO says folks.	Osiris30	May 3, 2012
Re: Honest question for the DXO says folks.	Peter 13	May 3, 2012
Osiris30: Some evidence of cooking of raw data in the 5D3, not in D800	Blade93012	May 3, 2012
Re: Osiris30: Some evidence of cooking of raw data in the 5D3, not in D800	Osiris30	May 3, 2012
Re: Osiris30: Some evidence of cooking of raw data in the 5D3, not in D800	yabokkie	May 3, 2012
Re: More grasping at straws	Macgupta	May 2, 2012
Re: Intersring Finding, must READ (5DM3 DR!!!)	Hans Kruse	May 2, 2012
Re: Intersring Finding, must READ (5DM3 DR!!!)	ihv	May 2, 2012
Re: Intersring Finding, must READ (5DM3 DR!!!) High read noise	Mikael Risedal	May 2, 2012
misleading	j900	May 2, 2012
Re: misleading	Mikael Risedal	May 2, 2012
I've said it for several months, DPP has less banding	BigG30	May 2, 2012
Re: I've said it for several months, DPP has less banding	Mikael Risedal	May 2, 2012
Facts and Physics READ OUT NOISE and DR	Mikael Risedal	May 2, 2012
Cheers bro	BigG30	May 2, 2012
Re: Facts and Physics READ OUT NOISE and DR	Osiris30	May 2, 2012
Canon is well aware of the issue	yabokkie	May 2, 2012
Please lets stop interacting with those ***** "OUTSIDERS" and ..	ArabiaSandStorm	May 2, 2012
Re: Please lets stop interacting with those ***** "OUTSIDERS" and ..	chironNYC	May 2, 2012
DPP is free nt	jamesfrmphilly	May 2, 2012
Re: Intersring Finding, must READ (5DM3 DR!!!)	Victor Engel	May 2, 2012
Files too small to judge anything	bgbs	May 2, 2012
There are NO firmware updates for.......	VivaLasVegas	May 2, 2012
Re: There are NO firmware updates for.......	SubPrime	May 2, 2012
Re: There are NO firmware updates for.......	ArabiaSandStorm	May 3, 2012
Re: There are NO firmware updates for.......	SubPrime	May 3, 2012
Re: There are NO firmware updates for.......	ArabiaSandStorm	May 3, 2012
Re: There are NO firmware updates for.......	SubPrime	May 3, 2012
Re: There are NO firmware updates for.......	ArabiaSandStorm	May 3, 2012
subprime	Brad Durack	May 3, 2012
Re: subprime	SubPrime	May 3, 2012
Re: subprime	GaryJP	May 3, 2012
GaryJP	SubPrime	May 3, 2012
Re: There are NO firmware updates for.......	SubPrime	May 3, 2012
Re: There are NO firmware updates for.......	ArabiaSandStorm	May 3, 2012
Re: There are NO firmware updates for.......	SubPrime	May 3, 2012
Re: There are NO firmware updates for.......	chironNYC	May 3, 2012
Re: There are NO firmware updates for.......	qianp2k	May 3, 2012
Re: There are NO firmware updates for.......	bgbs	May 3, 2012
Re: Files too small to judge anything	Jasper in SF	May 2, 2012
Re: Files too small to judge anything	rwbaron	May 2, 2012
Re: Files too small to judge anything	bgbs	May 3, 2012
Re: Intersring Finding, must READ (5DM3 DR!!!)	Peter 13	May 2, 2012
Re: Intersring Finding, must READ (5DM3 DR!!!)	Phil	May 2, 2012
Re: Intersring Finding, must READ (5DM3 DR!!!)	rwbaron	May 2, 2012
only surprise is how one gets stuck with high contrast shadows at all in good light??	sdyue	May 2, 2012
Re: only surprise is how one gets stuck with high contrast shadows at all in good lig	SubPrime	May 2, 2012
I think the point	Rick Knepper	May 3, 2012
Re: I think the point	ArabiaSandStorm	May 3, 2012
Re: I think the point	SubPrime	May 3, 2012
Re: I think the point	ArabiaSandStorm	May 3, 2012
Re: I think the point	SubPrime	May 3, 2012
Nothing new.	Phil Hill	May 3, 2012
Re: Nothing new.	Hans Kruse	May 3, 2012
Re: Nothing new.	Phil Hill	May 3, 2012
Re: Nothing new.	Phil Hill	May 3, 2012
And I'va never been able to get same results from DPP that match LR	ZAnton	May 3, 2012
Re: And I'va never been able to get same results from DPP that match LR	Phil Hill	May 3, 2012
Re: And I'va never been able to get same results from DPP that match LR	Hans Kruse	May 4, 2012
Re: And I'va never been able to get same results from DPP that match LR	Phil Hill	May 4, 2012
Re: And I'va never been able to get same results from DPP that match LR	Peter 13	May 4, 2012
Not only can I set up LR/ACR to match DPP	Kabe Luna	May 4, 2012
Re: Not only can I set up LR/ACR to match DPP	rwbaron	May 5, 2012
Unless he makes direct comparison of DR in LR vs. PS vs. DPP	ZAnton	May 3, 2012
Re: Unless he makes direct comparison of DR in LR vs. PS vs. DPP	GaryJP	May 3, 2012
Re: Unless he makes direct comparison of DR in LR vs. PS vs. DPP	Mikael Risedal	May 3, 2012
Re: Unless he makes direct comparison of DR in LR vs. PS vs. DPP	GaryJP	May 3, 2012
Re: Unless he makes direct comparison of DR in LR vs. PS vs. DPP	Mikael Risedal	May 5, 2012
Re: Unless he makes direct comparison of DR in LR vs. PS vs. DPP	Stone13	May 3, 2012
Re: Unless he makes direct comparison of DR in LR vs. PS vs. DPP	Ogjetaknight	May 3, 2012
Anyone else here duplicate results??	Daniel Clune	May 3, 2012
Re: Anyone else here duplicate results??	Mikael Risedal	May 3, 2012
Re: Anyone else here duplicate results??	Daniel Clune	May 3, 2012
Re: Anyone else here duplicate results??	Hans Kruse	May 4, 2012
SubPrime: do you own a 5DM3?	fjpyyy	May 3, 2012
Re: Intersring Finding, must READ (5DM3 DR!!!)	Shane Pope	May 4, 2012
Re: Intersring Finding, must READ (5DM3 DR!!!)	ArabiaSandStorm	May 4, 2012
Conclusion on the issue	ihv	May 4, 2012
Re: Conclusion on the issue	Peter 13	May 4, 2012
Re: Conclusion on the issue	Hans Kruse	May 4, 2012
Re: Conclusion on the issue	Peter 13	May 4, 2012
Re: Conclusion on the issue tudelu 5dmk2 , d800	Mikael Risedal	May 5, 2012
Re: Conclusion on the issue tudelu 5dmk2 , d800	Mikael Risedal	May 5, 2012

Keyboard shortcuts:

FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads

Color scheme? Blue / Yellow

Editorial content

Product database

Community

Would you move to a full frame DSLR?	150
FLICKR	135
Why is the 55-210 so big?	71
* this week through your m43 - 2013.05.20 *	69
Is it OK to "steal" pictures for school ...	65
Got Flowers? VOLUME 3	60
OMD Shutter shock revisited...and a possible ...	54
Sony A mount cameras could go mirrorless in 2014	53
Do you change lenses in the fields?	50
Omd Woes: How Prevalent?	46
Favorite walk-about lens	46
To owners of M4/3 and D-SLRs: which came first?	45
My Friend + his daughter for retouch	44
Pentax FF rumor gaining steam	39
Question for people who have used filters for ...	38
Why does my photo lack detail...?	38
Canon 10mm vs 18mm for landscapes	36
stolen D800 in Paris.	35
Has digital stitching made high megapixel ...	31
I sold my Canon...	28