Forum indexCanon EOS-1D / 5D / 6D TalkChange forum

5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding

Started Mar 6, 2012 | Discussions thread

Forum

Parent

First

Next unread

Flat view

Horshack

Senior Member • Posts: 2,948

Like?

5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding

Mar 6, 2012

Both files processed in CS5 ACR 6.7 RC, fill light +100.

5DM2 raw histogram:
Stop #Range Red Green Blue Green_2 Pct Pixels
0 [00000-00001] 0 0 0 0 0.00%
1 [00002-00003] 0 0 0 0 0.00%
2 [00004-00007] 0 0 0 0 0.00%
3 [00008-00015] 0 0 0 0 0.00%
4 [00016-00031] 0 0 0 0 0.00%
5 [00032-00063] 0 0 0 0 0.00%
6 [00064-00127] 0 0 0 0 0.00%
7 [00128-00255] 0 0 0 0 0.00%
8 [00256-00511] 0 0 0 0 0.00%
9 [00512-01023] 118,798 84,298 899,276 85,227 5.62%
10 [01024-02047] 5,164,618 5,198,040 4,384,391 5,194,287 94.31%
11 [02048-04095] 3,085 3,453 1,025 3,454 0.05%
12 [04096-08191] 1,006 1,628 0 1,637 0.02%
13 [08192-16383] 2 90 0 87 0.00%
14 [16384-32767] 0 0 0 0 0.00%
15 [32768-65535] 0 0 0 0 0.00%

5DM3 raw histogram:
Pixel counts for each raw stop:
Stop #Range Red Green Blue Green_2 Pct Pixels
0 [00000-00001] 0 0 0 0 0.00%
1 [00002-00003] 0 0 0 0 0.00%
2 [00004-00007] 0 0 0 0 0.00%
3 [00008-00015] 0 0 0 0 0.00%
4 [00016-00031] 0 0 0 0 0.00%
5 [00032-00063] 0 0 0 0 0.00%
6 [00064-00127] 0 0 0 0 0.00%
7 [00128-00255] 0 0 0 0 0.00%
8 [00256-00511] 0 0 0 0 0.00%
9 [00512-01023] 0 0 0 0 0.00%
10 [01024-02047] 110,062 112,679 180,017 125,473 2.26%
11 [02048-04095] 4,847,331 5,532,818 5,665,446 5,522,040 92.23%
12 [04096-08191] 888,191 200,001 478 197,978 5.50%
13 [08192-16383] 416 502 59 509 0.01%
14 [16384-32767] 0 0 0 0 0.00%
15 [32768-65535] 0 0 0 0 0.00%

Reply to thread Reply with quote Complain

Forum

Parent

First

Next unread

Flat view

Post (hide subjects)	Posted by	When
5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	Horshack	Mar 6, 2012
These are ISO 100 btw (nt)	Horshack	Mar 6, 2012
Re: These are ISO 100 btw (nt)	didd	Mar 6, 2012
Re: These are ISO 100 btw (nt)	Peter 13	Mar 7, 2012
Re: These are ISO 100 btw (nt)	John Sheehy	Mar 7, 2012
These are ISO 100 btw... under EV conditions which are supposed to...	sdyue	Mar 7, 2012
But in real life, mistakes are made,	Rick Knepper	Mar 7, 2012
Re: But in real life, mistakes are made,	David Hull	Mar 7, 2012
Re: But in real life, mistakes are made,	John Sheehy	Mar 7, 2012
Re: But in real life, mistakes are made,	David Hull	Mar 7, 2012
Re: But in real life, mistakes are made,	Horshack	Mar 7, 2012
Re: But in real life, mistakes are made,	rondhamalam	Mar 7, 2012
Re: But in real life, mistakes are made,	David Hull	Mar 7, 2012
Re: But in real life, mistakes are made,	David Hull	Mar 7, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	mandophoto	Mar 6, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	Apewithacamera	Mar 6, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	Dareshooter	Mar 6, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	rwbaron	Mar 6, 2012
Bandibrigade	Apewithacamera	Mar 6, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	bronxbombers	Mar 6, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	xerojay	Mar 6, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	John Sheehy	Mar 6, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	birdbrain	Mar 6, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	David Hull	Mar 6, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	gdanmitchell	Mar 6, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	mkln	Mar 7, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	octane2	Mar 7, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	bronxbombers	Mar 7, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	John Sheehy	Mar 7, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	octane2	Mar 7, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	Earthlight	Mar 7, 2012
or sunrises or pre-dawn	Rick Knepper	Mar 7, 2012
banding is not a friend (can the mkIII be this bad?)	hunk	Mar 6, 2012
Yellow bleed issue of the D800?	Apewithacamera	Mar 6, 2012
Re: Yellow bleed issue of the D800?	Victor Engel	Mar 6, 2012
Re: Yellow bleed issue of the D800?	Apewithacamera	Mar 6, 2012
Re: Yellow bleed issue of the D800?	rhlpetrus	Mar 6, 2012
Re: Yellow bleed issue of the D800?	Apewithacamera	Mar 6, 2012
Re: Yellow bleed issue of the D800?	rhlpetrus	Mar 6, 2012
Re: Yellow bleed issue of the D800?	Iliah Borg	Mar 6, 2012
Re: Yellow bleed issue of the D800?	Iliah Borg	Mar 6, 2012
Re: Yellow bleed issue of the D800?	bgbs	Mar 6, 2012
Re: Yellow bleed issue of the D800?	Mikael Risedal	Mar 6, 2012
Re: banding is not a friend (can the mkIII be this bad?)	oysso	Mar 7, 2012
Re: banding is not a friend (can the mkIII be this bad?)	hunk	Mar 7, 2012
+100 fill light, Whoa!	Schwany	Mar 6, 2012
Re: +100 fill light, Whoa!	John Sheehy	Mar 6, 2012
Re: +100 fill light, Whoa!	Schwany	Mar 6, 2012
Thank's But Where Did You Get the RAW from ...	rondhamalam	Mar 6, 2012
Raw is here...	Horshack	Mar 6, 2012
...	cs hauser	Mar 6, 2012
Re: ...	cs hauser	Mar 6, 2012
Re: ...	Horshack	Mar 6, 2012
Re: ...	bronxbombers	Mar 6, 2012
Re: ...	rwbaron	Mar 6, 2012
Re: ...	bronxbombers	Mar 6, 2012
Why would anyone think this means anything?	ESfishdoc	Mar 6, 2012
Re: Why would anyone think this means anything?	bronxbombers	Mar 6, 2012
Re: Why would anyone think this means anything?	Iliah Borg	Mar 6, 2012
Re: Why would anyone think this means anything?	Mikael Risedal	Mar 6, 2012
Re: Why would anyone think this means anything?	Iliah Borg	Mar 6, 2012
No one in the real world does	Vibrio	Mar 8, 2012
My take	Ghozer	Mar 7, 2012
Re: My take	bronxbombers	Mar 7, 2012
Re: My take	Ghozer	Mar 7, 2012
Re: My take	rwbaron	Mar 7, 2012
Re: My take	Ghozer	Mar 7, 2012
Re: My take	gdanmitchell	Mar 7, 2012
Re: My take	birdbrain	Mar 7, 2012
Re: My take	John Sheehy	Mar 7, 2012
Re: ...	John Sheehy	Mar 6, 2012
Banding is software induced	Vibrio	Mar 8, 2012
Question Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	rhlpetrus	Mar 6, 2012
Re: Question Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	Horshack	Mar 6, 2012
D4/D3s/D7000 shadows at base ISO Re: Question Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	rhlpetrus	Mar 6, 2012
Re: D4/D3s/D7000 shadows at base ISO Re: Question Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	Horshack	Mar 6, 2012
Re: Question Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	Fred Briggs	Mar 7, 2012
Re: Question Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	rhlpetrus	Mar 7, 2012
FAIL :-( [/nt]	Jakub Kubica	Mar 6, 2012
Re: FAIL :-( [/nt]	Vibrio	Mar 8, 2012
What about 1Dx ?	Jakub Kubica	Mar 6, 2012
Re: What about 1Dx ?	MM1	Mar 6, 2012
Re: What about 1Dx ?	Horshack	Mar 6, 2012
1Ds mark III has No Banding	rondhamalam	Mar 6, 2012
Re: What about 1Dx ?	John Sheehy	Mar 6, 2012
How disappointing!	jsmiller	Mar 6, 2012
oh nooesss, low iso still might not even match 1Ds3!?	bronxbombers	Mar 6, 2012
Re: oh nooesss, low iso still might not even match 1Ds3!?	John Sheehy	Mar 6, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	Iliah Borg	Mar 6, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	Horshack	Mar 6, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	Iliah Borg	Mar 6, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	Horshack	Mar 6, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	Iliah Borg	Mar 6, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	Horshack	Mar 6, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	DSPographer	Mar 7, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	John Sheehy	Mar 7, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	Earthlight	Mar 7, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	DSPographer	Mar 7, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	Iliah Borg	Mar 7, 2012
Wtf is that	Vibrio	Mar 8, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	Victor Engel	Mar 6, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	didd	Mar 6, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	Iliah Borg	Mar 6, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	bronxbombers	Mar 6, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	didd	Mar 6, 2012
Pathetic regurgitation of the band-of-brothers mantra	David Franklin	Mar 6, 2012
1DsIII has no banding, 5DII(III) doo, due to El cheapo electronics :( nt	gigamel	Mar 6, 2012
Re: Pathetic regurgitation of the band-of-brothers mantra	Iliah Borg	Mar 6, 2012
Re: Pathetic regurgitation of the band-of-brothers mantra	didd	Mar 6, 2012
1Ds3 was different though, it did have less banding than the 5D2 as well ahve all sai	bronxbombers	Mar 6, 2012
Re: 1Ds3 was different though, it did have less banding than the 5D2 as well ahve all	Mike_V	Mar 6, 2012
Do I see a Nikon in the horizon?	papparazzi	Mar 6, 2012
Re: Do I see a Nikon in the horizon?	Edymagno	Mar 6, 2012
So no banding then	Vibrio	Mar 6, 2012
Very Academic and Systematic	rondhamalam	Mar 6, 2012
If ever an issue polarised...	Dylthedog	Mar 6, 2012
Re: Very Academic and Systematic	Vibrio	Mar 7, 2012
Re: So no banding then	Jakub Kubica	Mar 7, 2012
You could be right	Vibrio	Mar 7, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	octane2	Mar 6, 2012
nothing at all to do with poor exposure settings	bronxbombers	Mar 6, 2012
Re: nothing at all to do with poor exposure settings	octane2	Mar 6, 2012
Re: nothing at all to do with poor exposure settings	David Hull	Mar 6, 2012
Re: nothing at all to do with poor exposure settings	bronxbombers	Mar 6, 2012
Re: nothing at all to do with poor exposure settings	David Hull	Mar 6, 2012
Re: nothing at all to do with poor exposure settings	bronxbombers	Mar 7, 2012
Re: nothing at all to do with poor exposure settings	David Hull	Mar 7, 2012
Re: nothing at all to do with poor exposure settings	rwbaron	Mar 7, 2012
Re: nothing at all to do with poor exposure settings	Horshack	Mar 7, 2012
Re: nothing at all to do with poor exposure settings	rwbaron	Mar 7, 2012
Re: nothing at all to do with poor exposure settings	David Hull	Mar 7, 2012
Re: nothing at all to do with poor exposure settings	Horshack	Mar 7, 2012
Re: nothing at all to do with poor exposure settings	bronxbombers	Mar 7, 2012
Re: Try RAW files	Glenn NK	Mar 7, 2012
Re: nothing at all to do with poor exposure settings	bronxbombers	Mar 7, 2012
Re: nothing at all to do with poor exposure settings	John Sheehy	Mar 7, 2012
Re: nothing at all to do with poor exposure settings	David Hull	Mar 7, 2012
I confess...	ESfishdoc	Mar 7, 2012
Re: nothing at all to do with poor exposure settings	John Sheehy	Mar 7, 2012
Re: nothing at all to do with poor exposure settings	Vibrio	Mar 8, 2012
Re: 5dM2 vs 5DM3 banding	birdbrain	Mar 6, 2012
If you want no banding with Canon glass	Edymagno	Mar 7, 2012
Re: If you want no banding with Canon glass	birdbrain	Mar 7, 2012
Aren't they embarrassed by this at Canon HQ?	Esbutt	Mar 7, 2012
Re: Aren't they embarrassed by this at Canon HQ?	Jakub Kubica	Mar 7, 2012
Re: Aren't they embarrassed by this at Canon HQ?	Earthlight	Mar 7, 2012
Re: Aren't they embarrassed by this at Canon HQ?	Vibrio	Mar 8, 2012
Interesting!	birdbrain	Mar 7, 2012
Full-sized sample of D7000 fill llight +100	Horshack	Mar 7, 2012
ISOLESS ........... it is	rondhamalam	Mar 7, 2012

Forum

Parent

First

Next unread

Keyboard shortcuts:

FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads

Color scheme? Blue / Yellow

Editorial content

Product database

Community

Why Canon made 1Dx best specification ... II	78
My first wedding with OMD	72
I would like to discuss the aesthetics of ...	69
Leica Mini M	68
Leica entering m4/3?	55
Is Apple getting people by their brain-balls?	52
Firmware upgrade causes AF slow down on 18-55!	49
about new XF55/200: I've seen only now	46
can you tell the IQ/ISO difference game: ...	45
2 Sigmas (19&30), or 20mm 1.7	41
Should I buy a NEX?	40
When size matters (D800 pixel count)	40
A few observations.	38
Hassy's Lunar gets real	38
*** MINI CHALLENGE 303 *** UNDER 6 MP ...	37
Just returned my 80-400mm VR AF-S lens	37
Seeking ways of tracking birds in flight with ...	35
New Forum?	35
Pentax — a Japanese Leica? Not really ...	33
What might go wrong with GX2	32