Girls Gone Vinyl
Thank you for taking time to write!
It is ambiguity of the second photo that actually makes it interesting. See, with how many stories you have already came up? Makes imagination gland pump its secret like no other
As to following your advice, I will abstain
The thing is, what you call selective color, which is, in fact, selective desaturation, used to be a groundbreaking technique when Eisenstein used it in his cinematographic masterpiece "Battleship Potyomkin" in 1925. Since then it has become so overused that at this point it is considered the worst cliche.