HX9 vs Panasonic GH2, TZ10, LX5 and Casio FH100

Started May 2, 2011 | Discussions thread
ForumParentFirstPreviousNextNext unread
Flat view
Alika
Forum MemberPosts: 99
Like?
HX9 vs Panasonic GH2, TZ10, LX5 and Casio FH100
May 2, 2011

In a nutshell, here is my summary of the results of the comparisons of two different crops each done with the SonyHX9, Panasonic GH2, TZ10, LX5 and Casio FH100.
Last week 21 user responded on the comparison No 1 and 7 for No 2 .

The motivation was to look at the same picture with exactly the same lightning condition for each camera. There is of course the limitation that the internal camera settings can play a role in the equation.
All comparison are at base ISO (80 -125; GH2 starts with 160)

For some more details see

http://forums.dpreview.com/forums/readflat.asp?forum=1009&message=38325585&q=Alika&qf=m

Quiz 1 in rank order:

  • Yellow Panasonic GH2: 21 user judged best or 2nd best (out of them 6 times ranked best)

  • Green Sony HX9: 21 best or 2nd best (out of them 5 times ranked best)

  • Blue Panasonic TZ10/ZS7: 3 worst ; 1 best or 2nd best

  • Purple Casio FH100: 3 worst

  • Pink Panasonic LX5: 13 worst

Quiz 2 in rank order::

  • Yellow Panasonic GH2: 7 user judged best or 2nd best (out of them 5 times ranked best)

  • Pink Sony HX9: 7 best or 2nd best (this time no one ranked best)

  • Green Panasonic LX5: 1 best or 2nd best

  • Purple Panasonic TZ10/ZS7: 3 worst 1 best or 2nd best

  • Blue Casio FH100: 4 worst

Results:

  • First surprise, for both quizes the GH2 and the HX9 were equally judged as best IQ. However, the 2. quiz shows a clear winner: the GH2, followed by the HX9!

  • Second surprise: the LX5 did worst in the first quiz but was better judged in the 2. quiz where it got the 3. rank.

You will find the source under http://www.fotomagazin.de/test_technik/testbilder/index.php . Select “Hersteller” = Sony, then select “> mehr” and then double click on “Visueller Testaufbau in allen ISO-Stufen”

ForumParentFirstPreviousNextNext unread
Flat view
ForumParentFirstPreviousNextNext unread
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow