Well, I know there are lots of this type of thread, but I figure that's why we all hang around here. And my wife seems disinterested...
I have the 7D and 28-135 kit lens. Going to buy one lens for now, mainly for family portraits, etc. Would like to do macro at some point, but not necessary. I had planned on getting a 50mm prime, as I loved that on my last camera. Then I thought that I might want a zoom in case I've been limiting myself to 50mm shots. So, after reading all sorts of things, I've narrowed it down to:
50/2.5 macro (1:2)
Sigma 18-50/2.8 macro (1:3)
So, do you think that I'll miss the extra 2 stops if I get the Tamron or Sigma, or one of the macro primes, instead of the 50/1.4 or 85/1.8? Will I be limiting myself with a prime if I don't get one of the zooms? Or should I get a prime for portraits, etc., and keep the 28-135 for a walking around lens if I want a zoom?
This is not the most scientific question, but I always value the opinions, thoughts, and ramblings of other photogs.