Forum indexNikon SLR Lens TalkChange forum

Thom Hogan - Unplugged

Started Apr 6, 2010 | Discussion thread

Forum

Parent

First

Next unread

Flat view

VRII

Senior Member • Posts: 2,529

Like?

Thom Hogan - Unplugged

Apr 6, 2010

That is, I'm unplugging from Thom's opinions regarding lenses, they're just not credible anymore. His comments regarding the 17-35mm F/2.8 , the overwhelming marketing drool over the 24mm f/1.4 , his recent comments regarding 3rd party lenses vs nikkor when he only compares them to the 18-55mm and does not mention the grand canyon abyss that is pricing between consumer and pro glass and zero prosumer lenses for FX and severa.l other opinions regarding other lenses, have definetely convince me that his opinions regarding lenses just are not up to par anymore.

his camera reviews are still the best though.

Reply to thread Reply with quote Complain

Forum

Parent

First

Next unread

Flat view

Post (hide subjects)	Posted by	When
Thom Hogan - Unplugged	VRII	Apr 6, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	kbarros	Apr 6, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	slimandy	Apr 6, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	frederic fahraeus	Apr 6, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	VRII	Apr 6, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	stupormundi	Apr 6, 2010
In this review of the two lenses	exit here	Apr 6, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	photoforfun	Apr 7, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	Ilkka Nissilä	Apr 6, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	frederic fahraeus	Apr 6, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	daniyarm	Apr 6, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	VRII	Apr 6, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	Anthony Medici	Apr 6, 2010
apparently?	bboz	Apr 6, 2010
Re: apparently?	slimandy	Apr 6, 2010
Re: apparently?	Photo_AK	Apr 6, 2010
Re: apparently?	slimandy	Apr 6, 2010
Re: apparently?	Photo_AK	Apr 6, 2010
Re: apparently?	slimandy	Apr 6, 2010
Re: apparently?	Photo_AK	Apr 6, 2010
Re: apparently?	slimandy	Apr 6, 2010
Re: apparently?	PepsiCan	Apr 6, 2010
Re: apparently?	slimandy	Apr 6, 2010
Re: apparently?	acarodp	Apr 7, 2010
Re: apparently?	ladp	Apr 6, 2010
Re: apparently?	slimandy	Apr 6, 2010
Re: apparently?	douglas d	Apr 6, 2010
apples and oranges	F4SD3	Apr 6, 2010
Re: apparently?	slimandy	Apr 7, 2010
Re: apparently?	Photo_AK	Apr 6, 2010
Re: apparently?	slimandy	Apr 7, 2010
Re: apparently?	jwalker019	Apr 10, 2010
Re: apparently?	em_dee_aitch	Apr 10, 2010
Re: apparently?	VRII	Apr 6, 2010
Re: apparently?	Photo_AK	Apr 6, 2010
Re: apparently?	slimandy	Apr 6, 2010
Re: apparently?	VRII	Apr 6, 2010
Whoa boy	ResIpsa	Apr 6, 2010
Re: apparently?	em_dee_aitch	Apr 6, 2010
Re: apparently?	Photo_AK	Apr 7, 2010
Re: apparently?	em_dee_aitch	Apr 7, 2010
What did Thom Hogan actually say?	bboz	Apr 6, 2010
Re: What did Thom Hogan actually say?	slimandy	Apr 6, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	Chris Hoppe	Apr 6, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	creeker	Apr 6, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	AlexanderVC	Apr 6, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	Svein Skogen	Apr 6, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	larry15	Apr 6, 2010
That just goes to show you...	HeyItsJoel	Apr 6, 2010
Re: That just goes to show you...	frederic fahraeus	Apr 6, 2010
Take a deep breath------.	ffnikclif	Apr 6, 2010
Nope	Jim Keye	Apr 6, 2010
Re: Nope	Anthony Medici	Apr 6, 2010
I have a link for you	Jim Keye	Apr 7, 2010
Re: I have a link for you	Anthony Medici	Apr 7, 2010
fugetaboutit	Jim Keye	Apr 7, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	larrywilson	Apr 6, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	anotherMike	Apr 6, 2010
True,true	F4SD3	Apr 6, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	larrywilson	Apr 6, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	anotherMike	Apr 6, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	lanef	Apr 6, 2010
This may disappoint you	Fred Ferkel	Apr 6, 2010
Re: This may disappoint you	Lions	Apr 6, 2010
Re: This may disappoint you	punwit	Apr 6, 2010
Re: This may disappoint you	VRII	Apr 7, 2010
Well	Fred Ferkel	Apr 7, 2010
What does any of this have to do with Ken Rockwell?!?	moving_comfort	Apr 6, 2010
Re: What does any of this have to do with Ken Rockwell?!?	HeyItsJoel	Apr 6, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	Mitrajoon	Apr 6, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	lanef	Apr 7, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	slimandy	Apr 7, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	Mitrajoon	Apr 7, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	anotherMike	Apr 7, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	Fostereast	Apr 7, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	AWG_Pics	Apr 7, 2010
QC, is totally worthless!!	frederic fahraeus	Apr 7, 2010
Re: QC, is totally worthless!!	VRII	Apr 7, 2010
Re: QC, is totally worthless!!	frederic fahraeus	Apr 7, 2010
Re: QC, is totally worthless!!	larrywilson	Apr 7, 2010
Re: QC, is totally worthless!!	frederic fahraeus	Apr 7, 2010
Re: sample shots?	josh007	Apr 7, 2010
Re: sample shots?	frederic fahraeus	Apr 7, 2010
Another take on QC & Hi! to Fred!	JKirbs	Apr 9, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	ericfordh	Apr 7, 2010
Can I judge all your thoughts and ideas now?	Phil Flash	Apr 7, 2010
Re: Can I judge all your thoughts and ideas now?	slimandy	Apr 7, 2010
Re: Can I judge all your thoughts and ideas now?	edwardaneal	Apr 8, 2010
Re: Can I judge all your thoughts and ideas now?	em_dee_aitch	Apr 8, 2010
Re: Can I judge all your thoughts and ideas now?	edwardaneal	Apr 8, 2010
Re: Can I judge all your thoughts and ideas now?	em_dee_aitch	Apr 8, 2010
a question	edwardaneal	Apr 8, 2010
and another	edwardaneal	Apr 8, 2010
Re: and another	frederic fahraeus	Apr 8, 2010
Re: and another	myzel	Apr 8, 2010
Re: and another	photoforfun	Apr 8, 2010
Re: and another	Photo_AK	Apr 8, 2010
Re: and another	frederic fahraeus	Apr 8, 2010
Re: and another	em_dee_aitch	Apr 8, 2010
Re: and another	photoforfun	Apr 8, 2010
Re: and another	em_dee_aitch	Apr 8, 2010
Re: and another	slimandy	Apr 8, 2010
Re: and another	edwardaneal	Apr 8, 2010
Re: and another	slimandy	Apr 8, 2010
Re: and another	edwardaneal	Apr 8, 2010
Re: and another	F4SD3	Apr 8, 2010
Re: and another	em_dee_aitch	Apr 8, 2010
Re: and another	Photo_AK	Apr 8, 2010
well	edwardaneal	Apr 8, 2010
Re: well	em_dee_aitch	Apr 8, 2010
Re: well	edwardaneal	Apr 8, 2010
Re: Apology/Correction regarding Thom	em_dee_aitch	Apr 8, 2010
Re: well	em_dee_aitch	Apr 8, 2010
Re: well	edwardaneal	Apr 8, 2010
Re: well	photoforfun	Apr 9, 2010
Re: well	slimandy	Apr 9, 2010
Re: well	em_dee_aitch	Apr 9, 2010
Re: well	photoforfun	Apr 9, 2010
Re: well	em_dee_aitch	Apr 9, 2010
Re: well	em_dee_aitch	Apr 10, 2010
Re: well	Photo_AK	Apr 9, 2010
Re: well	em_dee_aitch	Apr 9, 2010
Re: and another	em_dee_aitch	Apr 8, 2010
Re: and another	zoomring	Apr 8, 2010
Re: and another	Photo_AK	Apr 8, 2010
Re: and another	slimandy	Apr 9, 2010
Re: and another	frederic fahraeus	Apr 9, 2010
re: more to a lens than center sharpness versus's edge sharpeness	larrywilson	Apr 8, 2010
Re: a question	em_dee_aitch	Apr 8, 2010
Re: Are other reviewers comments on topic.	Leonard Shepherd	Apr 8, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	GuillaumeF	Apr 8, 2010
Forum members who don't reveal their identity	backcountry	Apr 8, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	George Collazo	Apr 8, 2010
Lens Reviews - Thom is not alone	John W Peterson	Apr 9, 2010
Re: Thom Hogan - Unplugged	paulskimcb	Apr 9, 2010

Forum

Parent

First

Next unread

Keyboard shortcuts:

FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads

Color scheme? Blue / Yellow

Editorial content

Product database

Community

Would you move to a full frame DSLR?	127
weekly wildlife 5/19-5/26	66
Why is the 55-210 so big?	60
Got Flowers? VOLUME 3	59
Is it OK to "steal" pictures for school ...	55
FLICKR	54
* this week through your m43 - 2013.05.20 *	53
Favorite walk-about lens	46
Sony A mount cameras could go mirrorless in 2014	41
OMD Shutter shock revisited...and a possible ...	41
My Friend + his daughter for retouch	40
RX100 concerns...	37
Canon 10mm vs 18mm for landscapes	36
Backup, if you don’t do it, do it now	35
Pentax FF rumor gaining steam	34
Do you change lenses in the fields?	33
I am downright impressed.....with the X-E1!	33
K-30 prices dropping, rebate, inventories low. ...	32
Omd Woes: How Prevalent?	32
Why does my photo lack detail...?	31