Post (hide subjects)	Posted by	When
Just posted! Canon 18-200mm IS lens review!	Steen Bay	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Just posted! Canon 18-200mm IS lens review!	glitched	Oct 15, 2008
Same for Nikkor 18-200 VR, Sigma 18-200 OS etc etc :)	thw	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Just posted! Canon 18-200mm IS lens review!	olsem	Oct 15, 2008
Dig it out and repeat your "tests" ...	Ken Phillips	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Dig it out and repeat your "tests" ...	olsem	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Dig it out and repeat your	PC Wheeler	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Dig it out and repeat your "tests" ...	thw	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Just posted! Canon 18-200mm IS lens review!	Staale S	Oct 15, 2008
Here's the question then	dmonty	Oct 16, 2008
Re: Here's the question then	huismetdehaan	Oct 16, 2008
Re: Here's the question then	Staale S	Oct 16, 2008
Re: Here's the question then	Steve Balcombe	Oct 16, 2008
Re: Here's the question then	huismetdehaan	Oct 16, 2008
Re: Here's the question then	Steve Balcombe	Oct 16, 2008
Re: Here's the question then	huismetdehaan	Oct 17, 2008
Re: Here's the question then	dmonty	Oct 17, 2008
Re: just think outside your own world	Stefan V	Oct 17, 2008
Re: just think outside your own world	huismetdehaan	Oct 17, 2008
Re: just think outside your own world	PC Wheeler	Oct 17, 2008
Re: Here's the question then	Steve Balcombe	Oct 17, 2008
Re: Here's the question then	huismetdehaan	Oct 17, 2008
Why is Canon, as the dominant dslr brand, marketing such rubbish lenses?	Plusiotis	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Just posted! Canon 18-200mm IS lens review!	blackhawk13	Oct 15, 2008
Andy do us a favour	discopolana	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Andy do us a favour	pc168	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Just posted! Canon 18-200mm IS lens review!	stratplaya	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Just posted! Canon 18-200mm IS lens review!	Jogger	Oct 15, 2008
Rather have NO USM Than MICRO USM	AdamT	Oct 16, 2008
Re: Just posted! Canon 18-200mm IS lens review!	PC Wheeler	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Just posted! Canon 18-200mm IS lens review!	KyTom	Oct 15, 2008
Compared to the 17-85	pixel_colorado	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Compared to the 17-85	PC Wheeler	Oct 15, 2008
Yes, and that's how I'm taking it as well.	jonrobertp	Oct 16, 2008
Ouch. Glad I didn't buy this lens as a kit with my 50D :(	Oak and Acorn	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Ouch. Glad I didn't buy this lens as a kit with my 50D :(	PC Wheeler	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Ouch. Glad I didn't buy this lens as a kit with my 50D :(	pixel_colorado	Oct 15, 2008
Reviews and print sizes	Andy Westlake	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Reviews and print sizes	PC Wheeler	Oct 15, 2008
Sigma 18-200mm OS	Henry Richardson	Oct 15, 2008
PTLens	Henry Richardson	Oct 15, 2008
Touche	Oak and Acorn	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Touche	PC Wheeler	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Ouch. Glad I didn't buy this lens as a kit with my 50D :(	plantdoc	Oct 16, 2008
Very odd comment in this review	Alfisti	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Very odd comment in this review	Ehrik	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Just posted! Canon 18-200mm IS lens review!	Redteg94	Oct 15, 2008
Q for Andy on the geometric distortion	Ehrik	Oct 15, 2008
Long edge/short edge	Andy Westlake	Oct 15, 2008
Thanks, but	Ehrik	Oct 15, 2008
Sorry, my mistake	Andy Westlake	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Sorry, my mistake	Ehrik	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Sorry, my mistake	ItsMeOnly	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Sorry, my mistake	flaxi	Oct 15, 2008
Why compared to Nikon and not Sigma?	Chippy99	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Why compared to Nikon and not Sigma?	Andy Westlake	Oct 15, 2008
ahnks	antbrown	Oct 15, 2008
Re: ahnks	Andy Westlake	Oct 15, 2008
For Andy	RVNomad	Oct 15, 2008
Mmmmmmm	Sharpen	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Thanks	antbrown	Oct 15, 2008
USM	Andy Westlake	Oct 15, 2008
Re: USM	GeraldW	Oct 15, 2008
Video	SuperSport	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Video	Andy Westlake	Oct 15, 2008
Andy, thanks for the test . Appreciate it.	jonrobertp	Oct 15, 2008
Sigma 18-200mm OS	Henry Richardson	Oct 15, 2008
Re: I'd love to see a comparison with the Sigma too	Stefan V	Oct 15, 2008
Please compare to Tamron and Sigma	Absolutic	Oct 15, 2008
What?	Fred Ferkel	Oct 15, 2008
Not to me. I know about the Nikon, and want my Canon to be = or better. nt	jonrobertp	Oct 16, 2008
Andy, Ill send you my 4/3 Leica 14-150...	Tommy_2	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Just posted! Canon 18-200mm IS lens review!	Gr0ver	Oct 15, 2008
135mm performance - YUCK!	Eric Sorensen	Oct 15, 2008
Has anyone printed the samples...	pixel_colorado	Oct 15, 2008
So perf. = to Nikons...both rate "7" . I'l take that for a travel lens.	jonrobertp	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Has anyone printed the samples...	treaks	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Has anyone printed the samples...	Will Yee	Oct 18, 2008
Re: Has anyone printed the samples...	GeraldW	Oct 15, 2008
200mm not 200mm ????????	flaxi	Oct 15, 2008
I wonder how the IQ of this lens compares with the G7/9 lens of	jonrobertp	Oct 15, 2008
Re: I wonder how the IQ of this lens compares with the G7/9 lens of	GeraldW	Oct 15, 2008
Distance	Andy Westlake	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Distance	flaxi	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Distance	flaxi	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Distance	Bahi	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Distance	flaxi	Oct 15, 2008
One last time	Alfisti	Oct 16, 2008
Re: One last time	Steve Balcombe	Oct 16, 2008
Re: One last time	Alfisti	Oct 16, 2008
Re: One last time	Steve Balcombe	Oct 16, 2008
Re: One last time	Andreas Helke	Oct 16, 2008
Bokeh	Andreas Helke	Oct 16, 2008
Finally a good comment ! Woo-hoo !	jonrobertp	Oct 16, 2008
what is the fuss?	2005magnum	Oct 16, 2008
Re: what is the fuss?	pixel_colorado	Oct 18, 2008
Re: what is the fuss?	Will Yee	Oct 18, 2008
Re: Distance	Andy Westlake	Oct 15, 2008
Re: Andy..	Gr0ver	Oct 16, 2008
Re: Andy..	Andy Westlake	Oct 16, 2008
Re: Andy..	Gr0ver	Oct 16, 2008
Re: Distance	flaxi	Oct 16, 2008
Re: 200mm not 200mm ????????	Redteg94	Oct 15, 2008
Re: 200mm not 200mm ????????	flaxi	Oct 15, 2008
Re: 200mm not 200mm ????????	Redteg94	Oct 15, 2008
Re: 200mm not 200mm ????????	Redteg94	Oct 15, 2008
Re: 200mm not 200mm ????????	flaxi	Oct 15, 2008
Re: 200mm not 200mm ????????	Thu	Oct 15, 2008
Re: 200mm not 200mm ????????	GeraldW	Oct 15, 2008
Comparison with the Sigma 18-200 OS	Andreas Helke	Oct 16, 2008
Re: 200mm not 200mm ????????	flaxi	Oct 16, 2008
Re: Has anyone printed the samples...	2005magnum	Oct 16, 2008
Re: Has anyone printed the samples...	Will Yee	Oct 18, 2008
Re: Just posted! Canon 18-200mm IS lens review!	JATO	Oct 15, 2008
I had my share of kit lens	Bogdan Spineanu	Oct 16, 2008
Another lazy lens for....	Mongrel	Oct 16, 2008
Lack of IQ & USM proves it's not worth the MSRP...	Prestidigitator	Oct 16, 2008
Re: Lack of IQ & USM proves it's not worth the MSRP...	plantdoc	Oct 17, 2008
Re: Lack of IQ & USM proves it's not worth the MSRP...	Henry Richardson	Oct 17, 2008
Re: Lack of IQ & USM proves it's not worth the MSRP...	plantdoc	Oct 18, 2008
Clients may be saying the same thing about your images after they leave. :)	jonrobertp	Oct 18, 2008
Re: Lack of IQ & USM proves it's not worth the MSRP...	Andreas Helke	Oct 17, 2008
Re: Lack of IQ & USM proves it's not worth the MSRP...	PC Wheeler	Oct 17, 2008
Re: Lack of IQ & USM proves it's not worth the MSRP...	blackhawk13	Oct 17, 2008
Good point. I was expecting better and more expensive too.	Paul De Bra	Oct 18, 2008
Have both 17-55 2.8 and 18-200 and will use both...'cause the short lens	jonrobertp	Oct 20, 2008
Re: it would be so much more peacefull here...	Stefan V	Oct 16, 2008
Re: it would be so much more peacefull here...	pixel_colorado	Oct 16, 2008
Exactly !	jonrobertp	Oct 16, 2008
How many lenses/samples were tested in this review?	Arn	Oct 16, 2008
One single sample	Andy Westlake	Oct 16, 2008
thanks for the informative reply! (nt)	Arn	Oct 16, 2008
Re: One single sample	plantdoc	Oct 18, 2008
Good question!	Paul De Bra	Oct 18, 2008
Re:18-200 question not answered	dmonty	Oct 18, 2008
Re:18-200 question not answered	Gr0ver	Oct 18, 2008
Mike..thanks. Seems the Nikon folk are more gracious.	jonrobertp	Oct 18, 2008
Lighrules LOVES the new Tamron 18-270 VC.	thw	Oct 18, 2008
Re: Lighrules LOVES the new Tamron 18-270 VC.	Gr0ver	Oct 18, 2008
thw..did he post a review of Canon's 18-200? don't see it there.	jonrobertp	Oct 18, 2008
Re: he doesn't say anything about the speed of AF	Stefan V	Oct 18, 2008
I don't know about "loves" it... ;)	lightrules	Oct 18, 2008
Re: Another 18-270 (@Nikon) success story	Stefan V	Oct 19, 2008
Sample gallery is very limited, Andy	ngari	Oct 18, 2008
Re: Sample gallery is very limited, Andy	PC Wheeler	Oct 18, 2008
Re: Sample gallery is very limited, Andy	ngari	Oct 18, 2008
Re: Sample gallery is very limited, Andy	Will Yee	Oct 19, 2008
Re: Sample gallery is very limited, Andy Added Moon Shots!	Will Yee	Oct 19, 2008
Samples indicate a very good resolution, worthy of the rating of 8/10. And	jonrobertp	Oct 20, 2008
Re: Samples indicate a very good resolution, worthy of the rating of 8/10. And	ngari	Oct 20, 2008

Forum

Parent

First

Next unread

Keyboard shortcuts:

FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads

Color scheme? Blue / Yellow

Editorial content

Product database

Community

I Will Not Shot in RAW	75
weekly wildlife 5/19-5/26	58
Is it OK to "steal" pictures for school ...	50
Why is the 55-210 so big?	46
* this week through your m43 - 2013.05.20 *	45
Favorite walk-about lens	41
Got Flowers? VOLUME 3	38
Would you move to a full frame DSLR?	38
RX100 concerns...	35
OMD Shutter shock revisited...and a possible ...	34
I am downright impressed.....with the X-E1!	33
Backup, if you don’t do it, do it now	33
K-30 prices dropping, rebate, inventories low. ...	32
Canon 10mm vs 18mm for landscapes	32
FLICKR	32
Sony A mount cameras could go mirrorless in 2014	29
Old cafe in Llanystumdwy for play	29
My Friend + his daughter for retouch	26
Expect Bad SD cards?	25
Alternative to FT-1 Adapter	24