QUICK LINKS:VideosSample ImagesCamera TimelineLink Directory

connect.dpreview.com geasrshop.dpreview.com

News ReviewsBuying GuideSample Images Articles Cameras Lenses Printers Software Forums Galleries Challenges

Forum indexPro Digital TalkChange forum

Jill Greenberg's McCain Photo...Ethical???

Started Sep 15, 2008 | Discussion thread

Parent

First

Previous

drowley

Regular Member • Posts: 291

Like?

Jill Greenberg's McCain Photo...Ethical???

Sep 15, 2008

Did she stomp all over her professional responsibility and/or reputation? She does amazing work, but she should not have allowed her politics interfere with her work.

It is all just a joke to her. I don't find her attitude funny at all. Extremely unprofessional.

http://www.wnd.com/index.php?fa=PAGE.view&pageId=75279

Your thoughts?

--
Darren Rowley

http://www.cloudsonfire.com

Reply to thread Reply with quote Complain

Parent

First

Previous

Post (hide subjects)	Posted by	When
Jill Greenberg's McCain Photo...Ethical???	drowley	Sep 15, 2008
Re: Jill Greenberg's McCain Photo...Ethical???	Jeff Behm	Sep 15, 2008
Re: Jill Greenberg's McCain Photo...Ethical???	Arved	Sep 15, 2008
Re: Jill Greenberg's McCain Photo...Ethical???	owenleve	Sep 15, 2008
Why should her political affiliation matter?	Kaikopere	Sep 15, 2008
McCain will never see it anyway because...	Roscolo	Sep 15, 2008
Re: McCain will never see it anyway because...	Rob Kircher	Sep 15, 2008
Re: McCain will never see it anyway because...	Will64	Sep 16, 2008
Injuries? What injuries? One can still use computer...	Roscolo	Sep 16, 2008
Re: Injuries? What injuries? One can still use computer...	lanef	Sep 16, 2008
Re: Jill Greenberg's McCain Photo...Ethical???	Maurice Smith	Sep 15, 2008
Re: Jill Greenberg's McCain Photo...Ethical???	Charles Self	Sep 15, 2008
I think her attitude reflects. . .	Paul Grupp	Sep 15, 2008
Re: I think her attitude reflects. . .	Chad Marek	Sep 15, 2008
Good for Jill	Jeff Maanum	Sep 15, 2008
Re: Good for Jill	Maurice Smith	Sep 15, 2008
She has caused even more distrust of photography and photographers	doug572	Sep 15, 2008
ever so slightly OT, from a complete outsider	Rriley	Sep 15, 2008
To me, there's 2 issues here	doug572	Sep 15, 2008
Re: I think her attitude reflects. . .	Jeff Behm	Sep 15, 2008
Re: I think her attitude reflects. . .	Charles Self	Sep 15, 2008
Re: Jill Greenberg's McCain Photo...Ethical???	RHeath	Sep 15, 2008
agreed: unprofessional, unethical, but legal?	Dave Largent	Sep 15, 2008
Re: agreed: unprofessional, unethical, but legal?	Maurice Smith	Sep 15, 2008
Re: agreed: unprofessional, unethical, but legal?	Rob Kircher	Sep 15, 2008
Re: agreed: unprofessional, unethical, but legal?	Maurice Smith	Sep 15, 2008
she was commissioned to make a complimentary photo	Dave Largent	Sep 15, 2008
Re: agreed: unprofessional, unethical, but legal?	Rob Kircher	Sep 15, 2008
Re: agreed: unprofessional, unethical, but legal?	Jeff Behm	Sep 15, 2008
Re: agreed: unprofessional, unethical, but legal?	Rob Kircher	Sep 15, 2008
Statement by the Atlantic	Chato	Sep 17, 2008
Re: Statement by the Atlantic	Rob Kircher	Sep 17, 2008
Re: Statement by the Atlantic	Chato	Sep 17, 2008
Re: Statement by the Atlantic	Suntan	Sep 17, 2008
Re: Statement by the Atlantic	Chato	Sep 17, 2008
Re: Statement by the Atlantic	Suntan	Sep 18, 2008
Re: Statement by the Atlantic	verve	Sep 18, 2008
Re: Statement by the Atlantic	Rob Kircher	Sep 18, 2008
Re: Statement by the Atlantic	verve	Sep 18, 2008
LOL... This has got to be the funniest exuse yet.	Rob Kircher	Sep 18, 2008
You are in charge of yourself, no other	verve	Sep 18, 2008
Re: You are in charge of yourself, no other	Rob Kircher	Sep 18, 2008
Re: You are in charge of yourself, no other	verve	Sep 18, 2008
Re: You are in charge of yourself, no other	Maurice Smith	Sep 18, 2008
Re: Statement by the Atlantic	Rob Kircher	Sep 17, 2008
Re: Statement by the Atlantic	Chato	Sep 17, 2008
Re: Statement by the Atlantic	Rob Kircher	Sep 17, 2008
Re: Statement by the Atlantic	Chato	Sep 17, 2008
Re: Statement by the Atlantic	Rob Kircher	Sep 18, 2008
Re: Statement by the Atlantic	Suntan	Sep 18, 2008
poor little johnny mcbush...	angstrom	Sep 15, 2008
Re: poor little johnny mcbush...	Bali_Mirage	Sep 16, 2008
you miss the point,	angstrom	Sep 17, 2008
A little immature, if you ask me	dad_of_four	Sep 15, 2008
That day arrived years ago	Paul Grupp	Sep 15, 2008
Shows how much of a moron Jill Greenberg is... if you ask me	Mike Collins	Sep 15, 2008
Re: Shows how much of a moron Jill Greenberg is... if you ask me	Paul Grupp	Sep 15, 2008
Re: Shows how much of a moron Jill Greenberg is... if you ask me	Mike Collins	Sep 15, 2008
Re: Shows how much of a moron Jill Greenberg is... if you ask me	deuxcent	Sep 16, 2008
Great Cover - The Client loved it!	Chato	Sep 17, 2008
reputation??	Jerry Doctor	Sep 15, 2008
Re: Jill Greenberg's McCain Photo...Ethical???	Bill McLeod	Sep 15, 2008
Greenburg's not getting paid, is getting sued...	JohnClif	Sep 15, 2008
I hope the McCain people sue her pants off also (nt)	jusphotos	Sep 15, 2008
Re: Greenburg's not getting paid, is getting sued...	Maurice Smith	Sep 16, 2008
Re: Exremely "UN"-ethical	jusphotos	Sep 15, 2008
Re: Jill Greenberg's McCain Photo...Ethical???	rebotfc	Sep 15, 2008
Re: Jill Greenberg's McCain Photo...Ethical???	semper_fi	Sep 16, 2008
Re: Jill Greenberg's McCain Photo...Ethical???	jusphotos	Sep 16, 2008
Unethical and unprofessional	Doug J	Sep 16, 2008
Re: Unethical and unprofessional	Maurice Smith	Sep 16, 2008
Re: Unethical and unprofessional	Doug J	Sep 16, 2008
Re: Unethical and unprofessional	Maurice Smith	Sep 16, 2008
Re: Unethical and unprofessional	Doug J	Sep 16, 2008
What a laugh!	kober	Sep 18, 2008
Huh...WHAT!	verve	Sep 18, 2008
Re: Huh...WHAT!	kober	Sep 18, 2008
Re: Huh...WHAT!	verve	Sep 18, 2008
Re: What a laugh!	Maurice Smith	Sep 18, 2008
Re: What a laugh!	kober	Sep 18, 2008
since when are airbrushed carefully posed pictures "honest"	calson	Sep 15, 2008
Actually she did manipulate that image	Chato	Sep 17, 2008
McCain's handlers shouldn't have let him pose for her. /nt	jb_va2001	Sep 16, 2008
Add child abuse to her list of malfeasance?	drowley	Sep 16, 2008
She seems to be a bit of a child	Suntan	Sep 16, 2008
Just being controversial	Antonio Cotto	Sep 16, 2008
Re: Just being controversial	Maurice Smith	Sep 16, 2008
Re: Just being controversial	Rob Kircher	Sep 16, 2008
Re: Just being controversial	Maurice Smith	Sep 16, 2008
Dehumanizing people makes it easier to attack them	CommonSense	Sep 16, 2008
Re: Jill Greenberg's McCain Photo...Ethical???	Rcihardc	Sep 16, 2008
Welcome to the culture war	jizzer	Sep 16, 2008
Propaganda isn't good art	TimFeak	Sep 16, 2008
Re: Poli...... TICS	lanef	Sep 16, 2008
Re: Jill Greenberg's McCain Photo...Ethical???	PaulWa	Sep 16, 2008
Re: Jill Greenberg's McCain Photo...Ethical???	TimFeak	Sep 16, 2008
Re: Jill Greenberg's McCain Photo...Ethical???	Doug J	Sep 16, 2008
Her comments make her sound childish, shallow and a little bit	markeast	Sep 16, 2008
Re: Jill Greenberg's McCain Photo...Ethical???	Robert Bedwell	Sep 16, 2008
Where were his handlers?	BAK	Sep 16, 2008
BAK, you haven't read the actual story	RDKirk	Sep 16, 2008
PEOPLE: This is NOT a porlictical issue...	Rob Kircher	Sep 16, 2008
Re: PEOPLE: This is NOT a porlictical issue...	L M Lloyd	Sep 16, 2008
everything is porlictical!	angstrom	Sep 16, 2008
Re: everything is porlictical!	L M Lloyd	Sep 16, 2008
See that potted plant over there...it's political	RDKirk	Sep 16, 2008
Bingo!	Jeff Behm	Sep 16, 2008
It speaks volumes about her	jfriedl	Sep 16, 2008
Re: PEOPLE: This is NOT a porlictical issue...	Bill McLeod	Sep 16, 2008
well, i completely understand and agree.	tex	Sep 16, 2008
Re: well, i completely understand and agree.	L M Lloyd	Sep 16, 2008
Re: well, i completely understand and agree.	Bill McLeod	Sep 17, 2008
Insightful point	verve	Sep 17, 2008
You apparently haven't seen any of the images in question	RDKirk	Sep 17, 2008
oh, but I have!	verve	Sep 17, 2008
Re: well, i completely understand and agree.	L M Lloyd	Sep 17, 2008
Re: well, i completely understand and agree.	Bill McLeod	Sep 17, 2008
Re: well, i completely understand and agree.	L M Lloyd	Sep 17, 2008
Re: well, i completely understand and agree.	Bill McLeod	Sep 17, 2008
Re: well, i completely understand and agree.	L M Lloyd	Sep 17, 2008
Re: well, i completely understand and agree.	L M Lloyd	Sep 17, 2008
Re: well, i completely understand and agree.	Bill McLeod	Sep 17, 2008
Re: well, i completely understand and agree.	L M Lloyd	Sep 17, 2008
There is subjective, then there is subversive	Suntan	Sep 16, 2008
Re: There is subjective, then there is subversive	Jeff Behm	Sep 16, 2008
Re: There is subjective, then there is subversive	Rob Kircher	Sep 17, 2008
Re: PEOPLE: This is NOT a political issue...	Rob Kircher	Sep 17, 2008
Re: Jill Greenberg's McCain Photo...Ethical???	munro harrap	Sep 16, 2008
Re: Jill Greenberg's McCain Photo...Ethical???	mark currier	Sep 16, 2008
Re: Jill Greenberg's McCain Photo...Ethical???	Jeff Behm	Sep 16, 2008
Re: Jill Greenberg's McCain Photo...Ethical???	L M Lloyd	Sep 16, 2008
Absolutely....	Pam R	Sep 16, 2008
Re: Jill Greenberg's McCain Photo...Ethical???	Rdefen	Sep 17, 2008
Re: Jill Greenberg's McCain Photo...Ethical???	DigiDawg	Sep 17, 2008
And we wonder why no one trusts the press anymore	kober	Sep 17, 2008
Politics Aside...Can Your Client Trust You??	Port Royal Dad	Sep 17, 2008
stupid teenage prank	anyu	Sep 17, 2008
Re: Jill Greenberg's McCain Photo A+	jack Doeski	Sep 17, 2008

Parent

First

Previous

Keyboard shortcuts:

FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads

Color scheme? Blue / Yellow

Editorial content

Product database

Community

About us Write for us FAQ Feedback Interest-Based Ads Privacy Legal

All content, design, and layout are Copyright © 1998 - 2013 Digital Photography Review All Rights Reserved. Reproduction in whole or part in any form or medium without specific written permission is prohibited.

Mobile site