QUICK LINKS:VideosSample ImagesCamera TimelineLink Directory

connect.dpreview.com geasrshop.dpreview.com

News ReviewsBuying GuideSample Images Articles Cameras LensesPhonesPrinters Software Forums Galleries Challenges

Forum indexKonica Minolta TalkChange forum

Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?

Started Dec 22, 2005 | Discussions thread

Parent

First

Previous

codimac2

Regular Member • Posts: 170

Like?

Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?

Dec 22, 2005

I'm stumped. The 5D has gotten reviews that say it rivals the Rebel XT and D50...yet Digital Photography has yet to do a review...I don't get it. I would think that a site like this would be excited and anxious to review cameras like the 5D and the new Oly. They have had plenty of time to do a review, why haven't they?

Reply to thread Reply with quote Complain

Parent

First

Previous

Post (hide subjects)	Posted by	When
Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	codimac2	Dec 22, 2005
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	CAClark	Dec 22, 2005
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	codimac2	Dec 22, 2005
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	CAClark	Dec 22, 2005
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	Dave Oddie	Dec 22, 2005
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	mrfitz	Dec 22, 2005
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	Trevor G	Jan 6, 2006
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	mrfitz	Jan 6, 2006
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	Bart7D	Dec 22, 2005
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	codimac2	Dec 22, 2005
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	DonCrescas	Dec 22, 2005
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	Dominic Ryan	Dec 22, 2005
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	mrfitz	Dec 22, 2005
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	Yem	Jan 6, 2006
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	Eric Belko	Jan 6, 2006
his current project is probably the Nikon D200(nt)	James Gaba	Dec 22, 2005
Re: his current project is probably the Nikon D200(nt)	nooner	Dec 22, 2005
Re: his current project is probably the Nikon D200(nt)	Videoguy	Dec 22, 2005
I'm scared...	JulienHG	Dec 22, 2005
JulienHG - You have a problem with fLaming	Videoguy	Dec 22, 2005
pfff...	JulienHG	Dec 22, 2005
Re: pfff...	Videoguy	Dec 22, 2005
......Peace......	jstartin	Dec 22, 2005
Nope	saxe	Dec 22, 2005
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	imarollingstone	Dec 22, 2005
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	paul n	Dec 22, 2005
No, that's not correct..	tomes	Dec 22, 2005
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	Videoguy	Dec 22, 2005
He has it, it's coming, relax	imarollingstone	Dec 22, 2005
Re: He has it, it's coming, relax	Videoguy	Dec 22, 2005
I stand corrected :-)	paul n	Dec 22, 2005
Re: He has it, it's coming, relax	mrfitz	Dec 22, 2005
..I wouldn't hold my breath..	tomes	Dec 22, 2005
Re: ..I wouldn't hold my breath..	Amolmd	Dec 22, 2005
Re: ..I wouldn't hold my breath..	Dave Oddie	Dec 22, 2005
Should be close now....	celltech161	Dec 22, 2005
Re: Should be close now....	Gil Knutson	Dec 22, 2005
Re: Should be close now....	codimac2	Dec 22, 2005
Maybe close now....?	KEITH-C	Dec 22, 2005
Re: Should be close now....	mrfitz	Dec 22, 2005
Re: Should be close now....	CAClark	Dec 22, 2005
Reviews (Links)	gian	Dec 22, 2005
Other useful links	RFletcher	Dec 22, 2005
Lots of links to reviews of KM 5D...	Zdravko Kolev	Dec 22, 2005
Re: Lots of links to reviews of KM 5D...	Videoguy	Dec 22, 2005
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	josefnemecek	Dec 22, 2005
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	Videoguy	Dec 22, 2005
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	Pawel Kwasnicki	Dec 22, 2005
W h o C a r e s ! !	midwestshutterbug	Dec 22, 2005
Re: W h o C a r e s ! !	KEITH-C	Dec 22, 2005
Re: W h o C a r e s ! !	Videoguy	Dec 22, 2005
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	Amt0571	Dec 22, 2005
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	RacingManiac	Dec 22, 2005
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	Care4T	Dec 22, 2005
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	RacingManiac	Dec 22, 2005
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	RacingManiac	Dec 22, 2005
Phil have a other problem too...	Ari Aikomus	Dec 23, 2005
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	Gil Knutson	Jan 6, 2006
It is amazing that he hasn't	sej1001	Dec 23, 2005
Re: It is amazing that he hasn't	celltech161	Dec 23, 2005
Re: It is amazing that he hasn't	nooner	Dec 23, 2005
Re: It is amazing that he hasn't	codimac2	Jan 6, 2006
Re: It is amazing that he hasn't	mrfitz	Jan 6, 2006
Phil isn't the only game in town...	tapir	Jan 6, 2006
Re: Phil isn't the only game in town...	Jervell	Jan 6, 2006
Pity Imgaing-Resource is often overlooked...	tapir	Jan 6, 2006
It is your fault...	Darek Nikiel	Jan 6, 2006
Well....	KEITH-C	Jan 6, 2006
Re: Well....	kiklop_2	Jan 6, 2006
Re: Well....	wysiwyg05	Jan 6, 2006
Do Statistics Tell the truth?	Dave Huntoon	Jan 6, 2006
Re: Do Statistics Tell the truth?	DigiGuy	Jan 6, 2006
Re: THE ANSWER IS SIMPLE ...	Rouslan	Jan 6, 2006
Re: THE ANSWER IS SIMPLE ...	nooner	Jan 6, 2006
Re: THE ANSWER IS SIMPLE ...	KEITH-C	Jan 6, 2006
Re: Do Statistics Tell the truth?	Asher	Jan 7, 2006
Maybe it's KM and not Phil?	tapir	Jan 7, 2006
Re: Maybe it's KM and not Phil?	tomes	Jan 11, 2006
Re: Maybe it's KM and not Phil?	Miterman	Jan 11, 2006
Re: Maybe it's KM and not Phil?	Miterman	Jan 11, 2006
Your HP numbers are wrong -- S/B 4 OF 22	shoot123	Jan 9, 2006
Whewww...	Dave Huntoon	Jan 11, 2006
The big mess around the D200	JulienHG	Jan 7, 2006
Re: The big mess around the D200	KEITH-C	Jan 7, 2006
Re: The big mess around the D200	JulienHG	Jan 7, 2006
Top Selling Digital Cameras	Ari Aikomus	Jan 18, 2006
Hey....this is the real rub!!!	mrfitz	Jan 18, 2006
KM 5D Announced 15-Jul-05 !!	Ari Aikomus	Jan 18, 2006
Re: KM 5D Announced 15-Jul-05 !!	Ari Aikomus	Jan 19, 2006
Re: KM 5D Announced 15-Jul-05 !!	john farrar	Jan 19, 2006
MAybe they should review it as a tribute....	mrfitz	Jan 19, 2006
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	george solti	Jan 19, 2006
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	ywos	Jan 19, 2006
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	RacingManiac	Jan 19, 2006
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	nooner	Jan 19, 2006
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	Dayo	Jan 19, 2006
Why hasn't Phil reviewed ANYTHING recently?	shoot123	Feb 3, 2006
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed ANYTHING recently?	Gil Knutson	Feb 14, 2006
Re: Why hasn't Phil reviewed the 5D?	Erik Stiegler	Feb 3, 2006

Parent

First

Previous

Keyboard shortcuts:

FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads

Color scheme? Blue / Yellow

Editorial content

Product database

Community

About us Write for us FAQ Feedback Interest-Based Ads Privacy Legal

All content, design, and layout are Copyright © 1998 - 2013 Digital Photography Review All Rights Reserved. Reproduction in whole or part in any form or medium without specific written permission is prohibited.

Mobile site