S3, DR, and channel clipping
Joe Melillo wrote:
While recenly opening and posting photos to a PBase account, I
studied the DR of my photos, which were taken by three cameras:
Canon G2, Fuji S2, and Nikon 8700. I've become a lot more aware of
DR issues since reading all the coments about the S3, and there's
no question that I had a problem fitting the highlights and shadows
into the histogram with many of these pictures. As a sub-issue,
though, it seems that the blue channel was the hardest to control,
especially with the S2. Is this a common experience? Does the S3
do a better job of not just expanding overall DR but maintaining
consistency betwen the channels?
I cannot really answer your question. However, last Wednesday I went with a group on a photo shoot. Two photographers were trying to "get it right." I overheard them talking about their failure to get a good histogram of the scene. I took a shot we reviewed my S3's histogram and one commented - "Why that's perfect." I went on and they continued trying. I don't know what DSLRs they had. But I am confident that they won't bad mouth the S3.