digital cameras, digital camera: Digital Photography Review
News
Reviews
Cameras
Timeline
Buying Guide
Side-by-Side
Galleries
Forums
Search
Learn
Glossary
Feedback
Newsletter
Links
Support Us
About

Nikon Coolpix 950 vs. Canon Pro 70: Page Two

Page 1 | Page 2 | Page 3 | Page 4 | Page 5 | Page 6

Optics / CCD

  Nikon Coolpix 950 Canon Powershot Pro 70
CCD 2.11 megapixels 1/2"
(1600 x 1200 - 4:3 ratio)
R
GBG filter
1.68 megapixels 1/2"
(1536 x 1024 - 3:2 ratio)
C
YGM filter
Lens 38mm - 115mm (3x, F2.6 - F4)
3 secs from W to T
28mm - 70mm (2.5x, F2 - F2.4)
3.5 secs from W to T
Normal focus distance 30cm 32cm
Macro focus distance 2cm, smallest full frame:
18mm (3/4") across
12cm, smallest full frame:
64mm (2 3/4")

The Coolpix 950 is one of the new generation of "2 megapixel" cameras, you'll note however that horizontal resolution is pretty similar to that of the Pro 70 (plus 32 pixels either side) which was designed with a 3:2 picture ratio (the same as 35mm film). The Coolpix 950 also uses the fairly standard RGBG colour filter on the CCD however Canon have gone with the CYGM filter used on their other Powershot cameras (for a more detailed explanation of the workings of CCD's in digital cameras read the CCD section of my digital photography glossary).

One of the biggest complaints and "let-downs" of the Pro 70 is it's lack of "top end zoom", 70mm is almost half that of the CP950's top end, however the Pro 70 is unbeaten when it comes to perfectly flat (no distortion) wide angle (28mm) shots. The Coolpix 950 suffers from barrel distortion at wide angle and a strange colour fringing which has been put down to chromatic abberations (for more examples of this see the side-by-side samples later in this article).

Macro

The Coolpix 950 wins hands down when it comes to Macro shots, being able to get an amazing 3.5 times closer (horizontal coverage) than the Pro 70. The combination of the better macro optics and more powerful zoom on the Coolpix 950 can take down to an amazing 3/4" across the full frame allowing you to capture even the tiniest of details.

Nikon Coolpix 950 Canon Powershot Pro 70
(Click for larger image) (Click for larger image)

To show what kind of a difference this really makes the above shots were both taken of the same area of a circuit board at both cameras macro "sweet spot" - closest possible focus at maximum zoom (on the Coolpix 950 this is when the macro icon indicates green, on the Pro70 it's maximum zoom - 70mm). As you can see the Pro70 performed pretty poorly (get any closer than this and the Pro70 won't focus) however the 950 shined through getting right down to the details.

Standard Features

  Nikon Coolpix 950 Canon Powershot Pro 70
Flash Built-in, auto / red-eye / slow sync, external synch connector Not included, hotshoe
Shutter speed range 8 s - 1/750 s 1/2s - 1/500 s (1/8000s in low res)
Lower resolutions 1024 x 768, 640 x 480 768 x 512
ISO rating 80 / 100 / 160 / 320 100 / 200 (up to 400 in low res)
Manual focus 10 positions None
White balance override Yes - 5 positions plus manual presetting No
Exposure compensation -2EV to +2EV in 1/3EV steps -2EV to +2EV in 1/3EV steps
Metering modes 256 segment Matrix, Center-weighted average, Spot Center weighted
Continuous Yes (up to 1.5fps full size) Only at low res (up to 3fps)
Remote control No Yes
Uncompressed format TIFF (5.6MB) CCDRAW (1.9MB)
JPEG image compressions FINE (700KB) / NORMAL (400KB) / BASIC (250KB) FINE (400KB) / NORMAL (150KB)
Aperture priority 3 positions, at wide: F2.6 / F4.4 / F7.4 5 positions, at wide: F2 / F2.8 / F4.0 / F5.6 / F8.0
plus F8.0 + ND4 filter
Shutter priority 13 positions: 8s, 4s, 2s, 1s, 1/2s, 1/4s, 1/8s, 1/15s, 1/30s, 1/60s, 1/125s, 1/250s, 1/500s None (workaround is to use aperture priority)

As you can see by the above table the Nikon CP950 brings a range of "standard" (things you'd expect) features way ahead of the Pro 70. With three different metering modes, user selectable ISO, a bigger shutter speed range, white balance override and shutter priority the CP950 gives you that little extra flexibility to be more creative.

The built-in flash of the 950 is a vast improvement from that of the 900, although their have been some complaints that it produces slightly "pasty" skin tones there are some work-arounds (mostly aimed towards using different white-balance modes).

A word about the uncompressed format used, unfortunately Nikon didn't follow Canon's lead in using a CCDRAW format (which is later decoded into distinct 24-bit colour formats per pixel by a TWAIN driver on your PC/MAC) in real terms this means that on a 64MB CF card you'd be able to get 33 Pro70 uncompressed images but only 11 from the Coolpix 950. Combine this with the Pro70's ability to take the larger CF Type II cards and you'd be able to fit a whopping 178 uncompressed images on a 340MB IBM Microdrive. (Could Nikon introduce a new uncompressed format through a firmware update?)

Page One Page Three
 
 
Copyright 1998-2008 Digital Photography Review, dpreview.com Ltd.